{ "schema": "woc.engagement-closure-receipts.v1", "engagement": "MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "synthetic_notice": "SYNTHETIC — MOCK ENGAGEMENT. Every buyer disposition is simulated and labeled; buyer_disposition_authorization_id is null BY DESIGN — no human principal exists to authorize.", "receipt_shape": "CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §4 fields; routes ASSIGNED, never closed, until the follow-up cycle produces the §2 evidence", "findings_non_verified": 41, "receipts": [ { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-056", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-056/licence_number", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-056/licence_number", "gap_owner": "WOC-METHOD", "owner_basis": "the buyer row was corrupted ON PURPOSE by our fixture generator — the finding is a labeled test fixture, not a buyer defect; the demonstrated property is stated per fixture (R5-8)", "closure_route": "FIXTURE-BY-DESIGN", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "labeled-fixture-property", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-056#licence_number: the corrupted value is the test fixture — the demonstrated property is stated by the fixture labels (R5-8), never as a buyer defect" ] }, { "test_id": "no-buyer-action", "evidence_refs": [ "WOC-METHOD: a fixture finding routes to no buyer; the receipt exists to record ownership only" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "§4 no board record for licence \"9999999999\" — the invented licence does not exist in the SYNTHETIC FIXTURE board roster (fixture-authorities.json)", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": null, "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-056", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-056/provider_name", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-056/provider_name", "gap_owner": "WOC-METHOD", "owner_basis": "the buyer row was corrupted ON PURPOSE by our fixture generator — the finding is a labeled test fixture, not a buyer defect; the demonstrated property is stated per fixture (R5-8)", "closure_route": "FIXTURE-BY-DESIGN", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "labeled-fixture-property", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-056#provider_name: the corrupted value is the test fixture — the demonstrated property is stated by the fixture labels (R5-8), never as a buyer defect" ] }, { "test_id": "no-buyer-action", "evidence_refs": [ "WOC-METHOD: a fixture finding routes to no buyer; the receipt exists to record ownership only" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "§4 no board record for licence \"9999999999\" — the invented licence does not exist in the SYNTHETIC FIXTURE board roster — the name cannot be checked against a person that does not exist in the fixture roster (fixture-authorities.json)", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": null, "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-056", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-056/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-056/practice_address", "gap_owner": "WOC-METHOD", "owner_basis": "the buyer row was corrupted ON PURPOSE by our fixture generator — the finding is a labeled test fixture, not a buyer defect; the demonstrated property is stated per fixture (R5-8)", "closure_route": "FIXTURE-BY-DESIGN", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "labeled-fixture-property", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-056#practice_address: the corrupted value is the test fixture — the demonstrated property is stated by the fixture labels (R5-8), never as a buyer defect" ] }, { "test_id": "no-buyer-action", "evidence_refs": [ "WOC-METHOD: a fixture finding routes to no buyer; the receipt exists to record ownership only" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "§4 no board record for licence \"9999999999\" and no ground-truth address to check against (SYNTHETIC FIXTURE roster — fixture-authorities.json)", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": null, "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-057", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-057/provider_name", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-057/provider_name", "gap_owner": "WOC-METHOD", "owner_basis": "the buyer row was corrupted ON PURPOSE by our fixture generator — the finding is a labeled test fixture, not a buyer defect; the demonstrated property is stated per fixture (R5-8)", "closure_route": "FIXTURE-BY-DESIGN", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "labeled-fixture-property", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-057#provider_name: the corrupted value is the test fixture — the demonstrated property is stated by the fixture labels (R5-8), never as a buyer defect" ] }, { "test_id": "no-buyer-action", "evidence_refs": [ "WOC-METHOD: a fixture finding routes to no buyer; the receipt exists to record ownership only" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "the buyer-published name differs from the board roster name for this licence (board name \"Brandon K Samplefield\", buyer \"Margaret A. Totallydifferent, DDS\")", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "Brandon K Samplefield", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-058", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-058/provider_name", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-058/provider_name", "gap_owner": "WOC-METHOD", "owner_basis": "the buyer row was corrupted ON PURPOSE by our fixture generator — the finding is a labeled test fixture, not a buyer defect; the demonstrated property is stated per fixture (R5-8)", "closure_route": "FIXTURE-BY-DESIGN", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "labeled-fixture-property", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-058#provider_name: the corrupted value is the test fixture — the demonstrated property is stated by the fixture labels (R5-8), never as a buyer defect" ] }, { "test_id": "no-buyer-action", "evidence_refs": [ "WOC-METHOD: a fixture finding routes to no buyer; the receipt exists to record ownership only" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the board record for licence \"9000000581\" names \"Cassandra L Testerville\"; the NPPES record for the asserted NPI \"1900000571\" names \"BRANDON SAMPLEFIELD\" — with no Tier-A identifier link the corpora do not establish that these are two distinct published persons (a name-presentation variant remains possible; the two-persons assertion is inadmissible without subject binding — LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z), and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 9000000571; board licence \"9000000581\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). The finding is actionable as an identity ticket; the dependent address adjudication is blocked. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "Cassandra L Testerville", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — NPPES (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#nppes", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "BRANDON SAMPLEFIELD", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1900000571", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "9000000571" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-058", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-058/npi", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-058/npi", "gap_owner": "WOC-METHOD", "owner_basis": "the buyer row was corrupted ON PURPOSE by our fixture generator — the finding is a labeled test fixture, not a buyer defect; the demonstrated property is stated per fixture (R5-8)", "closure_route": "FIXTURE-BY-DESIGN", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "labeled-fixture-property", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-058#npi: the corrupted value is the test fixture — the demonstrated property is stated by the fixture labels (R5-8), never as a buyer defect" ] }, { "test_id": "no-buyer-action", "evidence_refs": [ "WOC-METHOD: a fixture finding routes to no buyer; the receipt exists to record ownership only" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the asserted NPI \"1900000571\" is registered in NPPES to \"BRANDON SAMPLEFIELD\" (NPPES MO taxonomy license \"9000000571\"), while the board licence \"9000000581\" names \"Cassandra L Testerville\" — no identifier link establishes the NPI record as the same subject, and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 9000000571; board licence \"9000000581\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). This is the finding class a buyer pays for: an actionable identity ticket, never an auto-substituted identifier. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — NPPES (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#nppes", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "BRANDON SAMPLEFIELD", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1900000571", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "9000000571" }, { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "Cassandra L Testerville", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-058", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-058/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-058/practice_address", "gap_owner": "WOC-METHOD", "owner_basis": "the buyer row was corrupted ON PURPOSE by our fixture generator — the finding is a labeled test fixture, not a buyer defect; the demonstrated property is stated per fixture (R5-8)", "closure_route": "FIXTURE-BY-DESIGN", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "labeled-fixture-property", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-058#practice_address: the corrupted value is the test fixture — the demonstrated property is stated by the fixture labels (R5-8), never as a buyer defect" ] }, { "test_id": "no-buyer-action", "evidence_refs": [ "WOC-METHOD: a fixture finding routes to no buyer; the receipt exists to record ownership only" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 9000000571; board licence \"9000000581\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality); dependent address adjudication is blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 (a)) temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "303 Placeholder Dr, Nixa, MO, 65714", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — NPPES (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#nppes", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "202 Mockingbird Ct, Springfield, MO, 65804", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1900000571", "entity_type": "individual" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-059", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-059/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-059/practice_address", "gap_owner": "WOC-METHOD", "owner_basis": "the buyer row was corrupted ON PURPOSE by our fixture generator — the finding is a labeled test fixture, not a buyer defect; the demonstrated property is stated per fixture (R5-8)", "closure_route": "FIXTURE-BY-DESIGN", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "labeled-fixture-property", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-059#practice_address: the corrupted value is the test fixture — the demonstrated property is stated by the fixture labels (R5-8), never as a buyer defect" ] }, { "test_id": "no-buyer-action", "evidence_refs": [ "WOC-METHOD: a fixture finding routes to no buyer; the receipt exists to record ownership only" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "the buyer-published address differs from the board roster address for this licence (ZIP5 65801 vs 65721). Roles: buyer published practice location vs board address_of_record. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "404 Specimen Ave, Ozark, MO, 65721", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — NPPES (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#nppes", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "404 Specimen Ave, Ozark, MO, 65721", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1900000591", "entity_type": "individual" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-060", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-060/licence_number", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-060/licence_number", "gap_owner": "WOC-METHOD", "owner_basis": "the buyer row was corrupted ON PURPOSE by our fixture generator — the finding is a labeled test fixture, not a buyer defect; the demonstrated property is stated per fixture (R5-8)", "closure_route": "FIXTURE-BY-DESIGN", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "labeled-fixture-property", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-060#licence_number: the corrupted value is the test fixture — the demonstrated property is stated by the fixture labels (R5-8), never as a buyer defect" ] }, { "test_id": "no-buyer-action", "evidence_refs": [ "WOC-METHOD: a fixture finding routes to no buyer; the receipt exists to record ownership only" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "STALE", "reason": "board licence expired 2026-08-01T00:00:00Z (before evaluation 2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z)", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "9000000601", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Expired", "expires_at": "2026-08-01T00:00:00Z" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-016", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-016/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-016/practice_address", "gap_owner": "WOC-METHOD", "owner_basis": "generator-omitted street per Tani 2026-09-14T06:44Z: the board publishes name + street and our roster generator omitted the street from the frozen buyer row — a WoC fixture defect, never a buyer ticket", "closure_route": "REMEDIATE_METHOD", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "woc-method-fix", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-016#practice_address — the defect is WoC’s (generator/method); the fix is ours: repair the generator/method, regenerate the frozen baseline, re-adjudicate" ] }, { "test_id": "never-a-buyer-route", "evidence_refs": [ "OWNERSHIP-1 (Tani 2026-09-14T06:44Z): a receipt can never route a WoC defect to a buyer — no buyer action is required or implied" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "the board publishes a practice name where the buyer publishes a partial line (name-shape publication — board line: \"Elevate Dental Studio\", street \"304 W Weaver Road\"): the buyer-published address differs from the board line as published (street line \"Elevate Dental Studio\" vs \"Elevate Dental Studio, 304 W Weaver Road\"). Roles: buyer published practice location vs board address_of_record. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Elevate Dental Studio, 304 W Weaver Road, Springfield, Missouri, 65810", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "name_shape_publication": true }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "4350 S NATIONAL AVE STE C112, SPRINGFIELD, MO, 65810", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1588194369", "entity_type": "individual" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-020", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-020/provider_name", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-020/provider_name", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-020 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the board record for licence \"2001015390\" names \"Kristen Kimberly Schreiner\"; the NPPES record for the asserted NPI \"1154164747\" names \"KENDALL CLINE\" — with no Tier-A identifier link the corpora do not establish that these are two distinct published persons (a name-presentation variant remains possible; the two-persons assertion is inadmissible without subject binding — LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z), and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 2024019627; board licence \"2001015390\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). The finding is actionable as an identity ticket; the dependent address adjudication is blocked. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Kristen Kimberly Schreiner", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "KENDALL CLINE", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1154164747", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "2024019627" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-020", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-020/npi", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-020/npi", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-020 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the asserted NPI \"1154164747\" is registered in NPPES to \"KENDALL CLINE\" (NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2024019627\"), while the board licence \"2001015390\" names \"Kristen Kimberly Schreiner\" — no identifier link establishes the NPI record as the same subject, and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 2024019627; board licence \"2001015390\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). This is the finding class a buyer pays for: an actionable identity ticket, never an auto-substituted identifier. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "KENDALL CLINE", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1154164747", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "2024019627" }, { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Kristen Kimberly Schreiner", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-020", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-020/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-020/practice_address", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-020 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 2024019627; board licence \"2001015390\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality); dependent address adjudication is blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 (a)) Both preserved readings AGREE after the v4 normalizations — the unresolved question is subject binding, not the address. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "485 SW Ward Rd, Lees Summit, Missouri, 64081", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "485 SW WARD RD, LEES SUMMIT, MO, 64081", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1154164747", "entity_type": "individual" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "485 SW WARD RD, LEES SUMMIT, MO, 64081", "role": "mailing", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1154164747", "entity_type": "individual", "context": "mailing address preserved as context — never contradiction fodder" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-010", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-010/provider_name", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-010/provider_name", "gap_owner": "WOC-METHOD", "owner_basis": "ROW-010 per Tani 2026-09-14T06:44Z: the finding traces to our method — the roster pairing artifact (an individual’s licence joined to an organization NPI); the entity-role constraint (R5-3) is our fix; never a buyer route", "closure_route": "REMEDIATE_METHOD", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "woc-method-fix", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-010#provider_name — the defect is WoC’s (generator/method); the fix is ours: repair the generator/method, regenerate the frozen baseline, re-adjudicate" ] }, { "test_id": "never-a-buyer-route", "evidence_refs": [ "OWNERSHIP-1 (Tani 2026-09-14T06:44Z): a receipt can never route a WoC defect to a buyer — no buyer action is required or implied" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "NPI entity-role finding (NPI-ROLE-1): the asserted NPI \"1033089750\" is registered in NPPES as an ORGANIZATION (\"DANIELLE WOLFE DDS LLC\", authorized official DANIELLE WOLFE) while the buyer row names an individual practitioner (\"Jeffrey P Smith\", board licensee \"Jeffrey P Smith\") — RULED (Tani 2026-09-14T15:15Z): the buyer's NPI field denotes the individual practitioner (NPPES entity type 1) — an organization NPI (entity type 2) in that field is erroneous against the ruled field contract. This is a ROLE finding, never a name mismatch; binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"013930\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Jeffrey P Smith", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "DANIELLE WOLFE DDS LLC", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1033089750", "entity_type": "organization", "authorized_official": "DANIELLE WOLFE" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-010", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-010/npi", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-010/npi", "gap_owner": "WOC-METHOD", "owner_basis": "ROW-010 per Tani 2026-09-14T06:44Z: the finding traces to our method — the roster pairing artifact (an individual’s licence joined to an organization NPI); the entity-role constraint (R5-3) is our fix; never a buyer route", "closure_route": "REMEDIATE_METHOD", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "woc-method-fix", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-010#npi — the defect is WoC’s (generator/method); the fix is ours: repair the generator/method, regenerate the frozen baseline, re-adjudicate" ] }, { "test_id": "never-a-buyer-route", "evidence_refs": [ "OWNERSHIP-1 (Tani 2026-09-14T06:44Z): a receipt can never route a WoC defect to a buyer — no buyer action is required or implied" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "NPI entity-role finding (NPI-ROLE-1): the asserted NPI \"1033089750\" is an ORGANIZATION-entity registration (\"DANIELLE WOLFE DDS LLC\", authorized official DANIELLE WOLFE) while the buyer row names the individual practitioner \"Jeffrey P Smith\" — an individual name paired with the organization's NPI is a ROLE finding, never a name mismatch; RULED (Tani 2026-09-14T15:15Z): the buyer's NPI field denotes the individual practitioner (NPPES entity type 1) — an organization NPI (entity type 2) in that field is erroneous against the ruled field contract. Never auto-substitute an identifier. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "DANIELLE WOLFE DDS LLC", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1033089750", "entity_type": "organization", "authorized_official": "DANIELLE WOLFE" }, { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Jeffrey P Smith", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-010", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-010/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-010/practice_address", "gap_owner": "WOC-METHOD", "owner_basis": "ROW-010 per Tani 2026-09-14T06:44Z: the finding traces to our method — the roster pairing artifact (an individual’s licence joined to an organization NPI); the entity-role constraint (R5-3) is our fix; never a buyer route", "closure_route": "REMEDIATE_METHOD", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "woc-method-fix", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-010#practice_address — the defect is WoC’s (generator/method); the fix is ours: repair the generator/method, regenerate the frozen baseline, re-adjudicate" ] }, { "test_id": "never-a-buyer-route", "evidence_refs": [ "OWNERSHIP-1 (Tani 2026-09-14T06:44Z): a receipt can never route a WoC defect to a buyer — no buyer action is required or implied" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"013930\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality); dependent address adjudication is blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 (a)) Both preserved readings AGREE after the v4 normalizations — the unresolved question is subject binding, not the address. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "3101 Droste Rd, St Charles, Missouri, 63301", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "3101 DROSTE RD, SAINT CHARLES, MO, 63301", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1033089750", "entity_type": "organization" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "1353 W GATEWAY HTS, SAINT LOUIS, MO, 63144", "role": "mailing", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1033089750", "entity_type": "organization", "context": "mailing address preserved as context — never contradiction fodder" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-051", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-051/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-051/practice_address", "gap_owner": "WOC-METHOD", "owner_basis": "generator-omitted street per Tani 2026-09-14T06:44Z: the board publishes name + street and our roster generator omitted the street from the frozen buyer row — a WoC fixture defect, never a buyer ticket", "closure_route": "REMEDIATE_METHOD", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "woc-method-fix", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-051#practice_address — the defect is WoC’s (generator/method); the fix is ours: repair the generator/method, regenerate the frozen baseline, re-adjudicate" ] }, { "test_id": "never-a-buyer-route", "evidence_refs": [ "OWNERSHIP-1 (Tani 2026-09-14T06:44Z): a receipt can never route a WoC defect to a buyer — no buyer action is required or implied" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "the board publishes a practice name where the buyer publishes a partial line (name-shape publication — board line: \"Jump Dental LLC\", street \"1300 N. Oakland Avenue, Ste. C\"): the buyer-published address differs from the board line as published (street line \"Jump Dental LLC\" vs \"Jump Dental LLC, 1300 N. Oakland Avenue, Ste. C\"). Roles: buyer published practice location vs board address_of_record. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Jump Dental LLC, 1300 N. Oakland Avenue, Ste. C, Bolivar, Missouri, 65613", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "name_shape_publication": true }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "1402 S ELLIOTT AVE STE A, AURORA, MO, 65605", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1770964116", "entity_type": "individual" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-023", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-023/provider_name", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-023/provider_name", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-023 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the board record for licence \"2012015521\" names \"Jerell James Wilson\"; the NPPES record for the asserted NPI \"1538270384\" names \"JAMES WILSON\" — with no Tier-A identifier link the corpora do not establish that these are two distinct published persons (a name-presentation variant remains possible; the two-persons assertion is inadmissible without subject binding — LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z), and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 12558; board licence \"2012015521\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). The finding is actionable as an identity ticket; the dependent address adjudication is blocked. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Jerell James Wilson", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "JAMES WILSON", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1538270384", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "12558" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-023", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-023/npi", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-023/npi", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-023 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the asserted NPI \"1538270384\" is registered in NPPES to \"JAMES WILSON\" (NPPES MO taxonomy license \"12558\"), while the board licence \"2012015521\" names \"Jerell James Wilson\" — no identifier link establishes the NPI record as the same subject, and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 12558; board licence \"2012015521\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). This is the finding class a buyer pays for: an actionable identity ticket, never an auto-substituted identifier. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "JAMES WILSON", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1538270384", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "12558" }, { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Jerell James Wilson", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-023", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-023/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-023/practice_address", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-023 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 12558; board licence \"2012015521\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality); dependent address adjudication is blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 (a)) temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "180 Shortleaf Pine Drive, Saint Charles, Missouri, 63304", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "509 S MISSOURI ST, MACON, MO, 63552", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1538270384", "entity_type": "individual" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "509 S MISSOURI ST, MACON, MO, 63552", "role": "mailing", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1538270384", "entity_type": "individual", "context": "mailing address preserved as context — never contradiction fodder" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-001", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-001/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-001/practice_address", "gap_owner": "REGISTRY", "owner_basis": "documented source coverage — the authority corpora were read completely and the identifier is absent; no admissible route exists in scope", "closure_route": "ACCEPTED_LIMITATION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "documented-source-coverage-and-attempts", "evidence_refs": [ "findings.json#authority_corpora (board 9c17d20b… 4197 rows · NPPES 0131fe21… 1801 records — the complete lookup that proved absence)", "findings.json#rows/ROW-001/propositions/practice_address/readings" ] }, { "test_id": "exact-unresolved-question", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-001#practice_address: role comparability not established (R8-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z): the delivered NPPES object publishes the board-like address under the MAILING role (\"8500 MAR" ] }, { "test_id": "no-available-admissible-route", "evidence_refs": [ "both pinned corpora read completely; no third authority is in scope" ] }, { "test_id": "buyer-disposition-and-review-date", "evidence_refs": [ "null — SYNTHETIC buyer; simulated disposition only" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "role comparability not established (R8-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z): the delivered NPPES object publishes the board-like address under the MAILING role (\"8500 MARYLAND AVE APT 507, CLAYTON, MO, 63124\"), while its practice location differs from the board address of record (ZIP5 63124 vs 63104) — a NPPES mailing address is never contradiction fodder and role mismatch is not a contradiction (ADJUDICATION-2 (b)); the comparison the contradiction would need is role-mismatched, so the comparison is refused and both readings are preserved. Roles: board address_of_record vs NPPES practice location vs NPPES mailing (context). Subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2024025025\" = board licence \"2024025025\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "8500 Maryland Ave, Apt 507, Clayton, Missouri, 63124", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "2229 S 12TH ST, SAINT LOUIS, MO, 63104", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1891533618", "entity_type": "individual" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "8500 MARYLAND AVE APT 507, CLAYTON, MO, 63124", "role": "mailing", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1891533618", "entity_type": "individual", "context": "the board-like address as published by NPPES — under the mailing role; never contradiction fodder" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-007", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-007/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-007/practice_address", "gap_owner": "REGISTRY", "owner_basis": "the buyer-published value agrees with the board (address_of_record) and the NPPES registry practice-location entry differs — the open question is the REGISTRY entry (role/date evidence), not a buyer correction", "closure_route": "REGISTRY_INVESTIGATION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "role-and-date-evidence", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — which address role is the buyer’s required publication, and are the differing readings contemporaneous service locations (falsifier: valid multiple/role-specific locations)" ] }, { "test_id": "buyer-disposition-with-valid-authorization", "evidence_refs": [ "null — SYNTHETIC buyer; no human principal exists to authorize (see authorization note)" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "the buyer address matches the board roster, but the NPPES practice location for the asserted NPI differs — the two authorities disagree (ZIP5 65807 vs 65803). Subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2005000386\" = board licence \"2005000386\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1). Roles: board address_of_record vs NPPES practice location. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "3649 S Suburban Ave, Springfield, Missouri, 65807", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "2105 W KEARNEY ST, SPRINGFIELD, MO, 65803", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1255450763", "entity_type": "individual" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-012", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-012/provider_name", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-012/provider_name", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-012 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2024037183\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). ADJUDICATION-2 (a) requires Tier-A identifier equality before any cross-authority comparison is asserted; the comparison is blocked and both readings are preserved. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Marzieh Currimbhoy", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "MARZIEH CURRIMBHOY", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1124708391", "entity_type": "individual" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-012", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-012/npi", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-012/npi", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-012 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2024037183\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). ADJUDICATION-2 (a) requires Tier-A identifier equality before any cross-authority comparison is asserted; the comparison is blocked and both readings are preserved. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Marzieh Currimbhoy", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "MARZIEH CURRIMBHOY", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1124708391", "entity_type": "individual" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-012", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-012/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-012/practice_address", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-012 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2024037183\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality); dependent address adjudication is blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 (a)) Both preserved readings AGREE after the v4 normalizations — the unresolved question is subject binding, not the address. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2712 Grover Crossing Drive, Wildwood, Missouri, 63040", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "2712 GROVER CROSSING DR, WILDWOOD, MO, 63040", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1124708391", "entity_type": "individual" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "2712 GROVER CROSSING DR, WILDWOOD, MO, 63040", "role": "mailing", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1124708391", "entity_type": "individual", "context": "mailing address preserved as context — never contradiction fodder" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-052", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-052/provider_name", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-052/provider_name", "gap_owner": "PUBLISHER", "owner_basis": "NPI entity-role finding (NPI-ROLE-1): the buyer resolves the contracted meaning of its NPI field (individual vs organization) — a role finding, never a name mismatch", "closure_route": "REMEDIATED_PUBLICATION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "same-subject-predicate-and-publication-scope", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-052#provider_name", "findings.json#rows/ROW-052/propositions/provider_name" ] }, { "test_id": "fresh-successful-observation-of-agreed-correction", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — follow-up cycle: re-read of the buyer-published directory row after correction" ] }, { "test_id": "buyer-disposition-with-valid-authorization", "evidence_refs": [ "null — SYNTHETIC buyer; no human principal exists to authorize (see authorization note)" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "NPI entity-role finding (NPI-ROLE-1): the asserted NPI \"1487139754\" is registered in NPPES as an ORGANIZATION (\"SLEEP WELL STL\", authorized official NATHAN HARTMAN) while the buyer row names an individual practitioner (\"Nathan Dean Hartman\", board licensee \"Nathan Dean Hartman\") — RULED (Tani 2026-09-14T15:15Z): the buyer's NPI field denotes the individual practitioner (NPPES entity type 1) — an organization NPI (entity type 2) in that field is erroneous against the ruled field contract. This is a ROLE finding, never a name mismatch; binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2008014681\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Nathan Dean Hartman", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "SLEEP WELL STL", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1487139754", "entity_type": "organization", "authorized_official": "NATHAN HARTMAN" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-052", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-052/npi", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-052/npi", "gap_owner": "PUBLISHER", "owner_basis": "NPI entity-role finding (NPI-ROLE-1): the buyer resolves the contracted meaning of its NPI field (individual vs organization) — a role finding, never a name mismatch", "closure_route": "REMEDIATED_PUBLICATION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "same-subject-predicate-and-publication-scope", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-052#npi", "findings.json#rows/ROW-052/propositions/npi" ] }, { "test_id": "fresh-successful-observation-of-agreed-correction", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — follow-up cycle: re-read of the buyer-published directory row after correction" ] }, { "test_id": "buyer-disposition-with-valid-authorization", "evidence_refs": [ "null — SYNTHETIC buyer; no human principal exists to authorize (see authorization note)" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "NPI entity-role finding (NPI-ROLE-1): the asserted NPI \"1487139754\" is an ORGANIZATION-entity registration (\"SLEEP WELL STL\", authorized official NATHAN HARTMAN) while the buyer row names the individual practitioner \"Nathan Dean Hartman\" — an individual name paired with the organization's NPI is a ROLE finding, never a name mismatch; RULED (Tani 2026-09-14T15:15Z): the buyer's NPI field denotes the individual practitioner (NPPES entity type 1) — an organization NPI (entity type 2) in that field is erroneous against the ruled field contract. Never auto-substitute an identifier. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "SLEEP WELL STL", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1487139754", "entity_type": "organization", "authorized_official": "NATHAN HARTMAN" }, { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Nathan Dean Hartman", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-052", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-052/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-052/practice_address", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-052 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2008014681\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality); dependent address adjudication is blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 (a)) Both preserved readings AGREE after the v4 normalizations — the unresolved question is subject binding, not the address. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2690 Gravois Rd, High Ridge, Missouri, 63049", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "2690 GRAVOIS RD, HIGH RIDGE, MO, 63049", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1487139754", "entity_type": "organization" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "2690 GRAVOIS RD, HIGH RIDGE, MO, 63049", "role": "mailing", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1487139754", "entity_type": "organization", "context": "mailing address preserved as context — never contradiction fodder" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-022", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-022/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-022/practice_address", "gap_owner": "REGISTRY", "owner_basis": "the buyer-published value agrees with the board (address_of_record) and the NPPES registry practice-location entry differs — the open question is the REGISTRY entry (role/date evidence), not a buyer correction", "closure_route": "REGISTRY_INVESTIGATION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "role-and-date-evidence", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — which address role is the buyer’s required publication, and are the differing readings contemporaneous service locations (falsifier: valid multiple/role-specific locations)" ] }, { "test_id": "buyer-disposition-with-valid-authorization", "evidence_refs": [ "null — SYNTHETIC buyer; no human principal exists to authorize (see authorization note)" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "the buyer address matches the board roster, but the NPPES practice location for the asserted NPI differs — the two authorities disagree (ZIP5 64057 vs 64633). Subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2025019620\" = board licence \"2025019620\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1). Roles: board address_of_record vs NPPES practice location. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "18025 Kent Circle, Independence, Missouri, 64057", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "718 HARVEST HILLS DR, CARROLLTON, MO, 64633", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1952090789", "entity_type": "individual" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-055", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-055/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-055/practice_address", "gap_owner": "REGISTRY", "owner_basis": "the buyer-published value agrees with the board (address_of_record) and the NPPES registry practice-location entry differs — the open question is the REGISTRY entry (role/date evidence), not a buyer correction", "closure_route": "REGISTRY_INVESTIGATION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "role-and-date-evidence", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — which address role is the buyer’s required publication, and are the differing readings contemporaneous service locations (falsifier: valid multiple/role-specific locations)" ] }, { "test_id": "buyer-disposition-with-valid-authorization", "evidence_refs": [ "null — SYNTHETIC buyer; no human principal exists to authorize (see authorization note)" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "the buyer address matches the board roster, but the NPPES practice location for the asserted NPI differs — the two authorities disagree (ZIP5 64081 vs 64030). Subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"MO 12663\" = board licence \"012663\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1). Roles: board address_of_record vs NPPES practice location. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2154 SW Forestpark Ct, Lees Summit, Missouri, 64081", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "12508 WINCHESTER AVE, GRANDVIEW, MO, 64030", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1164455234", "entity_type": "individual" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-034", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-034/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-034/practice_address", "gap_owner": "PUBLISHER", "owner_basis": "CROSS-STATE-1 rerun (R7-8, Tani 2026-09-15T00:33Z): the EXTRACT-1 parser fix landed and the rerun (at our expense, SERVICE-DEBT-1 discharged) emitted the cross-state finding — the buyer-published practice address (Missouri) is contradicted by the board's address of record (out-of-state, both states named in the finding); the buyer corrects its published row — never a WOC-METHOD extraction defect (that defect was ours and is fixed)", "closure_route": "REMEDIATED_PUBLICATION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "same-subject-predicate-and-publication-scope", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-034#practice_address", "findings.json#rows/ROW-034/propositions/practice_address" ] }, { "test_id": "fresh-successful-observation-of-agreed-correction", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — follow-up cycle: re-read of the buyer-published directory row after correction" ] }, { "test_id": "buyer-disposition-with-valid-authorization", "evidence_refs": [ "null — SYNTHETIC buyer; no human principal exists to authorize (see authorization note)" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "cross-state mismatch (CROSS-STATE-1, R7-8 rerun — Tani 2026-09-15T00:33Z): EXTRACT-1 history — our parser produced the \"MO\" — the board publishes Leawood, KANSAS 66209 (ba_state \"Kansas\" in the raw row); the parsed canonical carries state: None for this licence and the reading renderer defaulted to MO — an extraction defect, never a board publication — the defect was OURS (SERVICE-DEBT-1); the parser fix landed and THIS rerun, at our expense, emits the finding the blocked comparison owed: the buyer publishes the practice in Missouri while the board's address of record is out-of-state (state MO vs KANSAS) temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "12600 Sagamoore Rd, Leawood, Kansas, 66209", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "parsed_render": "the parser-fixed rendering — the board row’s true state preserved (EXTRACT-1 resolved)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "103 CONGRESS ST, BELTON, MO, 64012", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1538420401", "entity_type": "individual" }, { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry — RAW SOURCE", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10, raw line (shipped: engagement-corpora/DEN.TXT)", "value": "Kathleen Elizabeth Cooper — ba_address \"12600 Sagamoore Rd\", ba_city \"Leawood\", ba_state \"Kansas\", ba_zip \"66209\", ba_cnty \"Unknown/Out of State\" (raw DEN.TXT line 67, shipped: engagement-corpora/DEN.TXT)" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-030", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-030/provider_name", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-030/provider_name", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-030 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2026013800\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). ADJUDICATION-2 (a) requires Tier-A identifier equality before any cross-authority comparison is asserted; the comparison is blocked and both readings are preserved. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Umair Bajwa", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "UMAIR BAJWA", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1336870823", "entity_type": "individual" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-030", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-030/npi", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-030/npi", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-030 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2026013800\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). ADJUDICATION-2 (a) requires Tier-A identifier equality before any cross-authority comparison is asserted; the comparison is blocked and both readings are preserved. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Umair Bajwa", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "UMAIR BAJWA", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1336870823", "entity_type": "individual" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-030", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-030/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-030/practice_address", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-030 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2026013800\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality); dependent address adjudication is blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 (a)) temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "1353 Westhampton Woods Ct, Chesterfield, Missouri, 63005", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "2406 N BROAD ST, COLMAR, PA, 18915", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1336870823", "entity_type": "individual" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "1353 WESTHAMPTON WOODS CT, WILDWOOD, MO, 63005", "role": "mailing", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1336870823", "entity_type": "individual", "context": "mailing address preserved as context — never contradiction fodder" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-039", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-039/provider_name", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-039/provider_name", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-039 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the board record for licence \"014664\" names \"Craig M Alexander\"; the NPPES record for the asserted NPI \"1073545752\" names \"CURTIS ALEXANDER\" — with no Tier-A identifier link the corpora do not establish that these are two distinct published persons (a name-presentation variant remains possible; the two-persons assertion is inadmissible without subject binding — LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z), and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 014891; board licence \"014664\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). The finding is actionable as an identity ticket; the dependent address adjudication is blocked. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Craig M Alexander", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "CURTIS ALEXANDER", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1073545752", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "014891" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-039", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-039/npi", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-039/npi", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-039 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the asserted NPI \"1073545752\" is registered in NPPES to \"CURTIS ALEXANDER\" (NPPES MO taxonomy license \"014891\"), while the board licence \"014664\" names \"Craig M Alexander\" — no identifier link establishes the NPI record as the same subject, and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 014891; board licence \"014664\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). This is the finding class a buyer pays for: an actionable identity ticket, never an auto-substituted identifier. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "CURTIS ALEXANDER", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1073545752", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "014891" }, { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Craig M Alexander", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-039", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-039/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-039/practice_address", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-039 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 014891; board licence \"014664\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality); dependent address adjudication is blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 (a)) temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "450 S Parker, Olathe, Kansas, 66061", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "300 S PLATTE CLAY WAY, KEARNEY, MO, 64060", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1073545752", "entity_type": "individual" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "300 S PLATTE CLAY WAY, KEARNEY, MO, 64060", "role": "mailing", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1073545752", "entity_type": "individual", "context": "mailing address preserved as context — never contradiction fodder" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-031", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-031/provider_name", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-031/provider_name", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-031 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the board record for licence \"2025021095\" names \"Hitarth Maheshkumar Patel\"; the NPPES record for the asserted NPI \"1437929213\" names \"HETAL PATEL\" — with no Tier-A identifier link the corpora do not establish that these are two distinct published persons (a name-presentation variant remains possible; the two-persons assertion is inadmissible without subject binding — LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z), and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 2024022309; board licence \"2025021095\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). The finding is actionable as an identity ticket; the dependent address adjudication is blocked. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Hitarth Maheshkumar Patel", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "HETAL PATEL", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1437929213", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "2024022309" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-031", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-031/npi", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-031/npi", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-031 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the asserted NPI \"1437929213\" is registered in NPPES to \"HETAL PATEL\" (NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2024022309\"), while the board licence \"2025021095\" names \"Hitarth Maheshkumar Patel\" — no identifier link establishes the NPI record as the same subject, and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 2024022309; board licence \"2025021095\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). This is the finding class a buyer pays for: an actionable identity ticket, never an auto-substituted identifier. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "HETAL PATEL", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1437929213", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "2024022309" }, { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Hitarth Maheshkumar Patel", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-031", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-031/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-031/practice_address", "gap_owner": "UNRESOLVED-BINDING", "owner_basis": "the finding class is identity-linkage / the comparison is binding-blocked: the open question is the SUBJECT BINDING (Tier-A identifier evidence), not a publication correction — the identity ticket with fresh exact-identifier lookups (R5-4) is the route; dependent adjudication re-opens after binding", "closure_route": "BINDING_RESOLUTION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "identity-ticket-with-fresh-exact-identifier-lookups", "evidence_refs": [ "R5-4: fresh exact-identifier lookups on BOTH sides (NPI→name/license, license→NPI) as cited readings; never an auto-substituted identifier" ] }, { "test_id": "source-qualified-binding-decision", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — Tier-A identifier evidence establishing (or refuting) the subject binding" ] }, { "test_id": "re-adjudicate-dependent-fields-after-binding", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — ROW-031 dependent propositions re-open on the resolved binding" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 2024022309; board licence \"2025021095\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality); dependent address adjudication is blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 (a)) temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "219 lillian place, Bartlett, Illinois, 60103", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "305 E OSAGE ST, PACIFIC, MO, 63069", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1437929213", "entity_type": "individual" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "305 E OSAGE ST, PACIFIC, MO, 63069", "role": "mailing", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1437929213", "entity_type": "individual", "context": "mailing address preserved as context — never contradiction fodder" } ] } }, { "schema": "woc.closure-receipt.v1", "engagement_id": "engagement:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "sample_unit_id": "provider:ROW-048", "finding_verification_id": "verification:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/ROW-048/practice_address", "requested_proposition_id": "proposition:ROW-048/practice_address", "gap_owner": "PUBLISHER", "owner_basis": "CROSS-STATE-1 rerun (R7-8, Tani 2026-09-15T00:33Z): the EXTRACT-1 parser fix landed and the rerun (at our expense, SERVICE-DEBT-1 discharged) emitted the cross-state finding — the buyer-published practice address (Missouri) is contradicted by the board's address of record (out-of-state, both states named in the finding); the buyer corrects its published row — never a WOC-METHOD extraction defect (that defect was ours and is fixed)", "closure_route": "REMEDIATED_PUBLICATION", "closure_route_state": "ASSIGNED — not closed; closure requires the follow-up cycle evidence (CLOSURE-RECEIPT-v1 §2 falsifier)", "closure_requirements": [ { "test_id": "same-subject-predicate-and-publication-scope", "evidence_refs": [ "ROW-048#practice_address", "findings.json#rows/ROW-048/propositions/practice_address" ] }, { "test_id": "fresh-successful-observation-of-agreed-correction", "evidence_refs": [ "PENDING — follow-up cycle: re-read of the buyer-published directory row after correction" ] }, { "test_id": "buyer-disposition-with-valid-authorization", "evidence_refs": [ "null — SYNTHETIC buyer; no human principal exists to authorize (see authorization note)" ] } ], "buyer_disposition_authorization_id": null, "authorization_note": "SYNTHETIC buyer (Example Health Plan, invented) — no human principal exists; an authorization id would be fabricated. Route assignment is the machinery’s proposal; a real engagement closes only on a named principal’s authorization (§5).", "successor_verification_id": null, "follow_up_policy_ref": "follow-up:MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1/one-cycle — whether the correction appeared in the buyer-published directory and stayed corrected; misses and unavailable checks disclosed, never inferred", "issued_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z", "finding_summary": { "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "cross-state mismatch (CROSS-STATE-1, R7-8 rerun — Tani 2026-09-15T00:33Z): EXTRACT-1 history — our parser produced the \"MO\" — the board publishes Meridian, IDAHO 83646 (ba_state \"Idaho\" in the raw row); the parsed canonical carries state: None for this licence and the reading renderer defaulted to MO — an extraction defect, never a board publication — the defect was OURS (SERVICE-DEBT-1); the parser fix landed and THIS rerun, at our expense, emits the finding the blocked comparison owed: the buyer publishes the practice in Missouri while the board's address of record is out-of-state (state MO vs IDAHO) temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "1427 W Great Basin Dr, Meridian, Idaho, 83646", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "parsed_render": "the parser-fixed rendering — the board row’s true state preserved (EXTRACT-1 resolved)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "1217 E MAIN ST, LINN, MO, 65051", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1467156174", "entity_type": "individual" }, { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry — RAW SOURCE", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10, raw line (shipped: engagement-corpora/DEN.TXT)", "value": "Timothy Balzen — ba_address \"1427 W Great Basin Dr\", ba_city \"Meridian\", ba_state \"Idaho\", ba_zip \"83646\" (raw DEN.TXT line 3888, shipped: engagement-corpora/DEN.TXT)" } ] } } ], "signature": "xZOI5nyC21OGbGs5xubJUFJY9aEDiT5T6i9XFdOhw+1xHKZSeoWsc95r15Nf9L+ALcZ9o/4ZKvh2u3z0MnraDg==" }