{ "schema": "woc.engagement-findings.v1", "engagement": "MOCK-ENGAGEMENT-1", "buyer": "Example Health Plan (SYNTHETIC)", "synthetic_notice": "SYNTHETIC — MOCK ENGAGEMENT. The buyer is invented; every artifact of this engagement carries that label. Real provider rows carry ONLY real board/NPPES facts; the wrong values live ONLY on synthetic rows (invented persons).", "eval_at": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "ran_at": { "started_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.798Z", "finished_at": "2026-09-16T07:35:48.824Z" }, "field_scope": [ "provider_name", "licence_number", "npi", "practice_address" ], "comparison_laws": { "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)", "preconditions": "ADJUDICATION-2 — NO comparison is asserted before its preconditions hold. (a) SUBJECT BINDING: the kernel Tier-A rule (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1) — the ONLY Tier-A link between the board record and the NPPES record is MO-taxonomy-license equality after normalization; a name match is Tier-B and is REFUSED as subject binding (ROW-012, ROW-030 revert to UNVERIFIABLE \"binding not established\"). (b) FIELD ROLE: address readings carry roles (board address_of_record · NPPES practice location / mailing · buyer published practice location); a NPPES mailing address is never contradiction fodder; role mismatch is not a contradiction. (c) TEMPORAL SCOPE: every reading carries its as_of; every comparison reason states the corpus windows. (d) NORMALIZATION: city-component alias expansion (ST→SAINT in the city field only, never in a street suffix); unit-omission is a wave-off, not a conflict. A comparison that fails a precondition returns UNVERIFIABLE naming the precondition; both readings are preserved on every row, including precondition failures. DETERMINACY-1 (v6, Tani 2026-09-14T18:08Z R6-4) — one decision procedure, explicit precedence, refusal outcomes: (e) TWO-PERSONS DETERMINACY: different names plus an absent identifier link does NOT establish \"two different persons\" — it establishes only that the BUYER’S ASSOCIATION IS UNSUPPORTED; the finding states that narrower proposition with finding_class identity-linkage (the actionable ticket class) and never asserts two persons; a two-persons claim requires identifier-grade evidence from the authorities themselves. (f) ADDRESS COMPARABILITY: address_of_record and practice location are comparable ONLY when both readings bind the same predicate class, the same authority scope, and the same jurisdiction, with roles and as_of dates stated; when they are not comparable, the emitted result is UNVERIFIABLE naming the incomparability — never CONTESTED. (g) DATE-DIFFERENCE DETERMINACY: a date difference supports contradiction ONLY when both readings issue from the same authority scope within the same publication cycle; a difference between corpus dates (different fetch windows) emits the temporal-scope note — publication lag or a legitimate move remains possible — and NEVER itself a CONTESTED verdict. Falsifiers (ruled): a legitimate name change without a Tier-A link, and a legitimate address change between corpus dates, must NOT become a conflict. Precedence on overlap: (a) binding failure outranks everything (UNVERIFIABLE, precondition named); (b) incomparability (f) outranks comparison; (c) date-only differences (g) resolve to the temporal note, never a conflict.", "address": "case-fold; strip punctuation; collapse whitespace; USPS-standardize street-suffix, directional, and unit-designator tokens (DR/DRIVE→DR, N/NORTH→N, APT/APARTMENT→APT, SUITE→STE, …); the compared board line is the FULL published line — units included (a buyer address omitting a unit the board publishes is a real difference, named in the reason); compare ZIP5 separately (9-digit vs 5-digit is not a difference); match if the standardized forms are equal, or equal with all whitespace removed (\"LA QUESTA\" ≡ \"LAQUESTA\"); the board’s name-shape publications (a practice name where a street address is expected — 145 rows corpus-wide, e.g. ba_address \"Elevate Dental Studio,304 W Weaver Road\") are rendered and compared AS PUBLISHED, with the shape named in the finding reason — \"the board publishes a practice name where NPPES publishes a street address\" is a different sentence than \"the two authorities disagree\"; a remaining real difference stays CONTESTED", "name": "case-fold; strip punctuation; drop generational suffixes and credential tokens (JR SR II III IV DDS DMD MD PC INC LLC PLC PA); compare FIRST and LAST given-name tokens; middle names, case, and credentials are registry formatting, not contradictions; a different first or last token is a real difference. Known boundary case: ROW-023 (Jerell James Wilson vs JAMES WILSON) — plausibly a middle-name presentation, not provable from the corpora; stays CONTESTED with both readings for the reviewer to rule on", "licence": "compare digits with leading zeros stripped (\"013129\" ≡ \"13129\")", "npi": "compare the 10-digit NPI string exactly; NPI-ROLE-1 (RULED, Tani 2026-09-14T15:15Z): the buyer’s NPI field denotes the individual practitioner (NPPES entity type 1) — an organization NPI (entity type 2) in that field is a ROLE finding with its own reason, never a name mismatch, and every NPI reading cites the entity type (enumeration_type)", "note": "v1 was exact-match after case-fold + punctuation strip — it counted \"2001 Laquesta Dr\" vs \"2001 LA QUESTA DR\" as CONTESTED: a formatting artifact presented as a directory defect (NORMALIZATION-1, fixed in v2). v3 (PARSE-ADDRESS-1): the board reading must be the FULL published address line — units included, and the board’s name-shape publications (practice name in the address field) rendered as published with the shape named in the reason — never a truncated street-only rendering that hides what the board actually publishes. All three laws are published in ADJUDICATION-LAW.md; a reviewer may dispute any rule." }, "law_delta": { "superseded": [ "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v1 (exact-match; superseded by NORMALIZATION-1)", "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v2 (USPS standardization; street-only board line — superseded by PARSE-ADDRESS-1)", "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v3 (PARSE-ADDRESS-1; superseded by ADJUDICATION-2)", "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v4 (ADJUDICATION-2, Tani 2026-09-14T06:44Z; superseded by NPI-ROLE-1)", "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v5 (NPI-ROLE-1 RULED, Tani 2026-09-14T15:15Z; superseded by DETERMINACY-1)", "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v6 (DETERMINACY-1, Tani 2026-09-14T18:08Z — Astra R5 static review R6-4; superseded by STATE-ALIAS-1)", "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v7 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1, Tani 2026-09-15T00:33Z; superseded by LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1)" ], "current": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)", "findings": [ "NORMALIZATION-1 (Tani 2026-09-13T18:41Z): the v1 address law was exact-match after case-fold + punctuation strip — it counted \"2001 Laquesta Dr\" vs \"2001 LA QUESTA DR\" (the same address) as a cross-authority conflict. A method artifact presented as a directory defect is exactly what we refuse to sell. v2 standardizes per USPS and compares ZIP5.", "PARSE-ADDRESS-1 (Tani 2026-09-13T19:07Z): the v2 board reading dropped the second address line the board publishes (units; the name-shape street), rendering \"Elevate Dental Studio\" as the board’s whole address — a truncated reading that hid what the board actually publishes. RAW-SOURCE VERDICT (DEN.TXT line 1795, ba_address \"Elevate Dental Studio,304 W Weaver Road\"): the board GENUINELY publishes a practice name where a street address is expected (case b — 145 rows corpus-wide; not a parser column defect — the parser preserves both parts). v3 compares the FULL published line, units included, and the name-shape rows carry the different sentence: \"the board publishes a practice name where NPPES publishes a street address\", never a mere \"the two authorities disagree\".", "ADJUDICATION-2 (Tani 2026-09-14T06:44Z, R4 reviewer acceptance issue 1): v3 conflated publication mismatch, identity linkage, and a directory defect — it asserted cross-authority comparisons on name-only links (ROW-012, ROW-030), compared mailing addresses as contradictions, and promoted city-name presentation (St Charles vs SAINT CHARLES) to conflicts. v4 installs the preconditions before any CONTESTED: (a) subject binding via the kernel Tier-A identifier-equality rule (MO-taxonomy-license equality; CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1) with Tier-B name-match refusal — ROW-012 and ROW-030 revert to UNVERIFIABLE \"binding not established\"; (b) field roles (address_of_record · practice location · mailing) — a NPPES mailing address is never contradiction fodder, role mismatch is not a contradiction; (c) temporal scope stated per reading; (d) city-component alias expansion (ST→SAINT in the city field only) and unit-omission wave-offs. A comparison that fails a precondition returns UNVERIFIABLE naming the precondition; both readings are preserved on every row, including precondition failures. Identity-linkage mismatches (two different published persons, no Tier-A link) are CONTESTED with finding_class identity-linkage — the actionable ticket class — and their dependent address adjudication is blocked.", "NPI-ROLE-1 (Tani 2026-09-14T15:15Z, R5-3 completion): RULED — the buyer’s NPI field denotes the individual practitioner (NPPES entity type 1); an organization NPI (entity type 2) in that field is a ROLE finding with its own reason, never a name mismatch, and every NPI reading cites the entity type (enumeration_type). Resolves ROW-052 and ROW-010’s org-NPI question. The rule changes reasons and readings, never states — the v4→v5 delta is COMPUTED at computed flips v4→v5 = 0 (flips_v4_to_v5_total in this law_delta, computed by the run, never asserted) and computed counts v5 = 59 VERIFIED / 22 CONTESTED / 18 UNVERIFIABLE / 1 STALE (identical to v4). NUMERIC-CLAIM-1 (Tani 2026-09-15T05:21Z): every numeric claim in this law text carries the name of the computed value it describes; package-check leg [18] verifies each by name.", "DETERMINACY-1 (Tani 2026-09-14T18:08Z, Astra R5 static review R6-4): v6 publishes ONE decision procedure with explicit precedence and refusal outcomes. (e) TWO-PERSONS DETERMINACY: different names plus an absent identifier link does NOT establish “two different persons” — it establishes only that the buyer’s association is unsupported; the finding states that narrower proposition (finding_class identity-linkage) and never asserts two persons. (f) ADDRESS COMPARABILITY: address_of_record and practice location are comparable ONLY within the same predicate class, authority scope, and jurisdiction, with roles and dates bound; when incomparable the result is UNVERIFIABLE naming the incomparability — never CONTESTED. (g) DATE-DIFFERENCE DETERMINACY: a date difference supports contradiction ONLY within the same authority scope and publication cycle; a corpus-date difference emits the temporal-scope note (publication lag or a legitimate move remains possible), never itself a CONTESTED verdict. FALSIFIERS (ruled): a legitimate name change without a Tier-A link, and a legitimate address change between corpus dates, must NOT become a conflict — the v5→v6 delta is COMPUTED at computed flips v5→v6 = 4 (flips_v5_to_v6_total, computed by the run, never asserted) by the same differ that computes every other delta, and computed counts v6 = 55 VERIFIED / 26 CONTESTED / 18 UNVERIFIABLE / 1 STALE. AMENDED (Tani 2026-09-15T05:21Z, NUMERIC-CLAIM-1): the earlier note here asserted 0 flips — prose contradicting the bundle’s own computed value is Astra’s A3 class, and it is ours to disclose, not theirs to find. The four flips (ROW-021, ROW-028, ROW-033, ROW-019 practice_address VERIFIED→CONTESTED) are legitimate, not a regression: under v6 rules on the parser-fixed corpus, “Missouri” vs “MO” compares as a mismatch because STATE-ALIAS-1 is v7 law — the same four rows v7’s STATE-ALIAS-WAVEOFF flips return to VERIFIED (v6 constrains what a finding may SAY, never its state).", "STATE-ALIAS-1 (v7, Tani 2026-09-15T00:33Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1, the empty-environment reproduction gate): the clean-environment reproduction caught the shipped findings drifting from the regenerated output — four practice_address propositions (ROW-021, ROW-028, ROW-033, ROW-019) flipped VERIFIED→CONTESTED solely on the state component (\"Missouri\" vs \"MO\" — the same state) after the R7-8 parser fix made the board corpus publish full state names. Selling that string difference as a directory defect is exactly the NORMALIZATION-1 method-artifact class (Tani 2026-09-13T18:41Z); v7 extends the (d) normalization to the state component (USPS full name ≡ two-letter abbreviation, state field only — the same rule shape as the city ST→SAINT expansion). The v6→v7 delta is COMPUTED at computed counts v6 = 55 VERIFIED / 26 CONTESTED / 18 UNVERIFIABLE / 1 STALE (v6 rules on the parser-fixed corpus), then computed flips v6→v7 = 6 (flips_v6_to_v7_total, computed by the run, never asserted) — the four STATE-ALIAS-WAVEOFF flips above, each named in flips_v6_to_v7 with its reason — plus the two CROSS-STATE-1 rerun flips below. REPRO-PARITY-1 (standing law, Tani 2026-09-15T00:33Z): a reproduction command that produces different findings than the signed delivery is worse than no reproduction command — the package check now FAILS on any difference between the regenerated output and the shipped signed findings.", "CROSS-STATE-1 (v7, Tani 2026-09-15T00:33Z — R7-8 rerun): the EXTRACT-1 parser fix landed (the parsed board reading now carries the board's true state — Kansas/Idaho, never a defaulted MO), and the rerun at OUR expense (SERVICE-DEBT-1 discharged) emits the findings the blocked comparison owed: ROW-034 (buyer publishes the practice in Missouri; the board's address of record is Leawood, KANSAS) and ROW-048 (buyer publishes the practice in Missouri; the board's address of record is Meridian, IDAHO) adjudicate CONTESTED cross-state with both states named — a genuine cross-state difference is a buyer-facing finding, never an extraction defect. computed counts v7 = 59 VERIFIED / 24 CONTESTED / 16 UNVERIFIABLE / 1 STALE; the two rerun flips appear in flips_v6_to_v7 with kind CROSS-STATE-RERUN.", "DIFF-SIM-1 (found during the REPRO-DRIFT-1 disposition, 2026-09-15): R7-3's hand-rolled v5 emission simulation produced 56/6/38/0 — 30 spurious state flips against the RULED v5 — and the counts chain had aliased the v5 entry to the current counts, hiding it. The simulation is WITHDRAWN; the v5 baseline is the ruled v5 STATE rules (identical to v4, proven by the R5-3 staging regeneration: computed counts v5 = 59 VERIFIED / 22 CONTESTED / 18 UNVERIFIABLE / 1 STALE, identical to v4), the v5→v6 delta over that baseline is computed flips v5→v6 = 4 (flips_v5_to_v6_total, computed by the run, never asserted) — the four state-component mismatches on the parser-fixed corpus (“Missouri” vs “MO”) that v7’s STATE-ALIAS-1 wave-offs resolve, because STATE-ALIAS-1 is v7 law: a method artifact, never a regression (AMENDED, Tani 2026-09-15T05:21Z, NUMERIC-CLAIM-1: the earlier note here asserted 0 and contradicted the bundle’s own computed value — Astra’s A3 class; ours to disclose, not theirs to find) — and the v5 EMISSION wording simulation remains OUTSTANDING work — a state differ cannot measure emission differences, and this artifact does not claim it can.", "LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1 (v8, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — Astra round six R8-1, blocking): the law is enforced in the EMITTING branch, never in prose. With no Tier-A identifier link the corpora do not establish two distinct published persons — the narrower unsupported-association proposition is the only admissible emission (ROW-020/023/058 and two more carried the forbidden phrase in the v7-signed bundle — found by our own gate leg [16], our finding, not the reviewer catch). Role comparability is not satisfied by listing roles and adding a temporal note: a board-like address under the NPPES MAILING role with a differing LOCATION is the REFUSAL case (ROW-001 — a REAL row; the refusal fires on NO synthetic fixture row, re-verified this round: ROW-056’s fixture NPPES record carries both a LOCATION and a MAILING address, but its labeled defect is licence_number — the row never reaches the address cross-comparison). computed counts v8 = 59 VERIFIED / 23 CONTESTED / 17 UNVERIFIABLE / 1 STALE — computed flips v7→v8 = 1 (flips_v7_to_v8_total, computed by the run, never asserted: ROW-001 practice_address CONTESTED→UNVERIFIABLE), recomputed, never carried over.", "DELTA-ARITHMETIC-1 (Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — Astra round six R8-2, blocking, highest severity): every published delta is computed from its ACTUAL named input and output arrays and must reconstruct its own destination — apply the published flips to the published from-counts and land on the published to-counts, or the build fails (package-check leg [17], newest first). v3→v4 diffs resultsV4 (never the current results); v5→v6 diffs resultsV6 (never resultsV4); v6→v7 diffs the genuine v7 baseline (resultsV7 — the v7 rule-set recompute, never an alias of the current results); v7→v8 is the trivial first gate case: computed flips v7→v8 = 1 — one flip, one row, one reason. Historical baselines are immunized against later law changes — the v8 role-comparability refusal is law-versioned, OFF for v1-v7 recomputes (the counts.v4/v5 drift was exactly this leak, found by Tani read-back). Where a baseline genuinely cannot be rebuilt, the delta ships comparison-unavailable — never zero, never manufactured. One representation for one truth: law_delta.counts.vN is the only count shape — the counts_v1..v4 snake keys are removed and the gate fails on any second shape." ], "counts": { "v1": { "VERIFIED": 48, "CONTESTED": 32, "UNVERIFIABLE": 20, "STALE": 0 }, "v2": { "VERIFIED": 48, "CONTESTED": 32, "UNVERIFIABLE": 20, "STALE": 0 }, "v3": { "VERIFIED": 48, "CONTESTED": 32, "UNVERIFIABLE": 20, "STALE": 0 }, "v4": { "VERIFIED": 59, "CONTESTED": 22, "UNVERIFIABLE": 18, "STALE": 1 }, "v5": { "VERIFIED": 59, "CONTESTED": 22, "UNVERIFIABLE": 18, "STALE": 1 }, "v6": { "VERIFIED": 55, "CONTESTED": 26, "UNVERIFIABLE": 18, "STALE": 1 }, "v7": { "VERIFIED": 59, "CONTESTED": 24, "UNVERIFIABLE": 16, "STALE": 1 }, "v8": { "VERIFIED": 59, "CONTESTED": 23, "UNVERIFIABLE": 17, "STALE": 1 } }, "flips_v1_to_v2_total": 0, "flips_v1_to_v2": [], "flips_v2_to_v3_total": 0, "flips_v2_to_v3": [], "flips_v3_to_v4_total": 34, "flips_v3_to_v4": [ { "row_id": "ROW-056", "field": "npi", "from_v3": "UNVERIFIABLE", "to_v4": "VERIFIED", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-057", "field": "licence_number", "from_v3": "UNVERIFIABLE", "to_v4": "VERIFIED", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-057", "field": "provider_name", "from_v3": "UNVERIFIABLE", "to_v4": "CONTESTED", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-057", "field": "npi", "from_v3": "UNVERIFIABLE", "to_v4": "VERIFIED", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-057", "field": "practice_address", "from_v3": "UNVERIFIABLE", "to_v4": "VERIFIED", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-058", "field": "licence_number", "from_v3": "UNVERIFIABLE", "to_v4": "VERIFIED", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-058", "field": "provider_name", "from_v3": "UNVERIFIABLE", "to_v4": "CONTESTED", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-058", "field": "npi", "from_v3": "UNVERIFIABLE", "to_v4": "CONTESTED", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-059", "field": "licence_number", "from_v3": "UNVERIFIABLE", "to_v4": "VERIFIED", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-059", "field": "provider_name", "from_v3": "UNVERIFIABLE", "to_v4": "VERIFIED", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-059", "field": "npi", "from_v3": "UNVERIFIABLE", "to_v4": "VERIFIED", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-059", "field": "practice_address", "from_v3": "UNVERIFIABLE", "to_v4": "CONTESTED", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-060", "field": "licence_number", "from_v3": "UNVERIFIABLE", "to_v4": "STALE", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-060", "field": "provider_name", "from_v3": "UNVERIFIABLE", "to_v4": "VERIFIED", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-060", "field": "npi", "from_v3": "UNVERIFIABLE", "to_v4": "VERIFIED", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-060", "field": "practice_address", "from_v3": "UNVERIFIABLE", "to_v4": "VERIFIED", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-021", "field": "practice_address", "from_v3": "CONTESTED", "to_v4": "VERIFIED", "kind": "NORMALIZATION-WAVEOFF — v4 wave-offs (city alias / unit omission) resolved a v3 contest" }, { "row_id": "ROW-028", "field": "practice_address", "from_v3": "CONTESTED", "to_v4": "VERIFIED", "kind": "NORMALIZATION-WAVEOFF — v4 wave-offs (city alias / unit omission) resolved a v3 contest" }, { "row_id": "ROW-020", "field": "practice_address", "from_v3": "CONTESTED", "to_v4": "UNVERIFIABLE", "kind": "BINDING-BLOCK — v3 asserted a cross-authority comparison without subject binding; v4 refuses it under the Tier-A rule (ADJUDICATION-2 (a))" }, { "row_id": "ROW-033", "field": "practice_address", "from_v3": "CONTESTED", "to_v4": "VERIFIED", "kind": "NORMALIZATION-WAVEOFF — v4 wave-offs (city alias / unit omission) resolved a v3 contest" }, { "row_id": "ROW-010", "field": "practice_address", "from_v3": "CONTESTED", "to_v4": "UNVERIFIABLE", "kind": "BINDING-BLOCK — v3 asserted a cross-authority comparison without subject binding; v4 refuses it under the Tier-A rule (ADJUDICATION-2 (a))" }, { "row_id": "ROW-019", "field": "practice_address", "from_v3": "CONTESTED", "to_v4": "VERIFIED", "kind": "NORMALIZATION-WAVEOFF — v4 wave-offs (city alias / unit omission) resolved a v3 contest" }, { "row_id": "ROW-023", "field": "practice_address", "from_v3": "CONTESTED", "to_v4": "UNVERIFIABLE", "kind": "BINDING-BLOCK — v3 asserted a cross-authority comparison without subject binding; v4 refuses it under the Tier-A rule (ADJUDICATION-2 (a))" }, { "row_id": "ROW-012", "field": "provider_name", "from_v3": "VERIFIED", "to_v4": "UNVERIFIABLE", "kind": "BINDING-BLOCK — v3 verified a cross-authority leg on a name-only link; v4 refuses the binding (ADJUDICATION-2 (a))" }, { "row_id": "ROW-012", "field": "npi", "from_v3": "VERIFIED", "to_v4": "UNVERIFIABLE", "kind": "BINDING-BLOCK — v3 verified a cross-authority leg on a name-only link; v4 refuses the binding (ADJUDICATION-2 (a))" }, { "row_id": "ROW-012", "field": "practice_address", "from_v3": "CONTESTED", "to_v4": "UNVERIFIABLE", "kind": "BINDING-BLOCK — v3 asserted a cross-authority comparison without subject binding; v4 refuses it under the Tier-A rule (ADJUDICATION-2 (a))" }, { "row_id": "ROW-052", "field": "practice_address", "from_v3": "CONTESTED", "to_v4": "UNVERIFIABLE", "kind": "BINDING-BLOCK — v3 asserted a cross-authority comparison without subject binding; v4 refuses it under the Tier-A rule (ADJUDICATION-2 (a))" }, { "row_id": "ROW-034", "field": "practice_address", "from_v3": "CONTESTED", "to_v4": "UNVERIFIABLE", "kind": "BINDING-BLOCK — v3 asserted a cross-authority comparison without subject binding; v4 refuses it under the Tier-A rule (ADJUDICATION-2 (a))" }, { "row_id": "ROW-030", "field": "provider_name", "from_v3": "VERIFIED", "to_v4": "UNVERIFIABLE", "kind": "BINDING-BLOCK — v3 verified a cross-authority leg on a name-only link; v4 refuses the binding (ADJUDICATION-2 (a))" }, { "row_id": "ROW-030", "field": "npi", "from_v3": "VERIFIED", "to_v4": "UNVERIFIABLE", "kind": "BINDING-BLOCK — v3 verified a cross-authority leg on a name-only link; v4 refuses the binding (ADJUDICATION-2 (a))" }, { "row_id": "ROW-030", "field": "practice_address", "from_v3": "CONTESTED", "to_v4": "UNVERIFIABLE", "kind": "BINDING-BLOCK — v3 asserted a cross-authority comparison without subject binding; v4 refuses it under the Tier-A rule (ADJUDICATION-2 (a))" }, { "row_id": "ROW-039", "field": "practice_address", "from_v3": "CONTESTED", "to_v4": "UNVERIFIABLE", "kind": "BINDING-BLOCK — v3 asserted a cross-authority comparison without subject binding; v4 refuses it under the Tier-A rule (ADJUDICATION-2 (a))" }, { "row_id": "ROW-031", "field": "practice_address", "from_v3": "CONTESTED", "to_v4": "UNVERIFIABLE", "kind": "BINDING-BLOCK — v3 asserted a cross-authority comparison without subject binding; v4 refuses it under the Tier-A rule (ADJUDICATION-2 (a))" }, { "row_id": "ROW-048", "field": "practice_address", "from_v3": "CONTESTED", "to_v4": "UNVERIFIABLE", "kind": "BINDING-BLOCK — v3 asserted a cross-authority comparison without subject binding; v4 refuses it under the Tier-A rule (ADJUDICATION-2 (a))" } ], "flips_v4_to_v5_total": 0, "flips_v4_to_v5": [], "flips_v5_to_v6_total": 4, "flips_v5_to_v6": [ { "row_id": "ROW-021", "field": "practice_address", "from_v5": "VERIFIED", "to_v6": "CONTESTED", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-028", "field": "practice_address", "from_v5": "VERIFIED", "to_v6": "CONTESTED", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-033", "field": "practice_address", "from_v5": "VERIFIED", "to_v6": "CONTESTED", "kind": "OTHER" }, { "row_id": "ROW-019", "field": "practice_address", "from_v5": "VERIFIED", "to_v6": "CONTESTED", "kind": "OTHER" } ], "flips_v6_to_v7_total": 6, "flips_v6_to_v7": [ { "row_id": "ROW-021", "field": "practice_address", "from_v6": "CONTESTED", "to_v7": "VERIFIED", "kind": "STATE-ALIAS-WAVEOFF — v6 compared the state component as a raw string; the parser-fixed board corpus publishes \"Missouri\" where the buyer/NPPES publish \"MO\" — the same state. v7 normalizes the state component (STATE-ALIAS-1); a method artifact is not a directory defect (NORMALIZATION-1, Tani 2026-09-13T18:41Z; REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate, 2026-09-15T00:33Z)" }, { "row_id": "ROW-028", "field": "practice_address", "from_v6": "CONTESTED", "to_v7": "VERIFIED", "kind": "STATE-ALIAS-WAVEOFF — v6 compared the state component as a raw string; the parser-fixed board corpus publishes \"Missouri\" where the buyer/NPPES publish \"MO\" — the same state. v7 normalizes the state component (STATE-ALIAS-1); a method artifact is not a directory defect (NORMALIZATION-1, Tani 2026-09-13T18:41Z; REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate, 2026-09-15T00:33Z)" }, { "row_id": "ROW-033", "field": "practice_address", "from_v6": "CONTESTED", "to_v7": "VERIFIED", "kind": "STATE-ALIAS-WAVEOFF — v6 compared the state component as a raw string; the parser-fixed board corpus publishes \"Missouri\" where the buyer/NPPES publish \"MO\" — the same state. v7 normalizes the state component (STATE-ALIAS-1); a method artifact is not a directory defect (NORMALIZATION-1, Tani 2026-09-13T18:41Z; REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate, 2026-09-15T00:33Z)" }, { "row_id": "ROW-019", "field": "practice_address", "from_v6": "CONTESTED", "to_v7": "VERIFIED", "kind": "STATE-ALIAS-WAVEOFF — v6 compared the state component as a raw string; the parser-fixed board corpus publishes \"Missouri\" where the buyer/NPPES publish \"MO\" — the same state. v7 normalizes the state component (STATE-ALIAS-1); a method artifact is not a directory defect (NORMALIZATION-1, Tani 2026-09-13T18:41Z; REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate, 2026-09-15T00:33Z)" }, { "row_id": "ROW-034", "field": "practice_address", "from_v6": "UNVERIFIABLE", "to_v7": "CONTESTED", "kind": "CROSS-STATE-RERUN — the EXTRACT-1 parser fix landed and the R7-8 rerun (at our expense, SERVICE-DEBT-1 discharged) emits the finding the blocked comparison owed: the buyer publishes the practice in Missouri while the board's address of record is out-of-state (Tani 2026-09-15T00:33Z)" }, { "row_id": "ROW-048", "field": "practice_address", "from_v6": "UNVERIFIABLE", "to_v7": "CONTESTED", "kind": "CROSS-STATE-RERUN — the EXTRACT-1 parser fix landed and the R7-8 rerun (at our expense, SERVICE-DEBT-1 discharged) emits the finding the blocked comparison owed: the buyer publishes the practice in Missouri while the board's address of record is out-of-state (Tani 2026-09-15T00:33Z)" } ], "flips_v7_to_v8_total": 1, "flips_v7_to_v8": [ { "row_id": "ROW-001", "field": "practice_address", "from_v7": "CONTESTED", "to_v8": "UNVERIFIABLE", "kind": "ROLE-COMPARABILITY-REFUSAL — R8-1 (Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z): the delivered NPPES object publishes the board-like address under the MAILING role while its practice location differs; role mismatch is not a contradiction (ADJUDICATION-2 (b)) — the refusal case, enforced in the emitting branch (LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1)" } ], "binding_blocked_count": 14, "binding_blocked_by_row": { "ROW-020": 1, "ROW-010": 1, "ROW-023": 1, "ROW-012": 3, "ROW-052": 1, "ROW-034": 1, "ROW-030": 3, "ROW-039": 1, "ROW-031": 1, "ROW-048": 1 }, "normalization_waveoff_count": 4, "identity_class_count": 0, "formatting_only_count": 0, "formatting_only_by_field": {}, "parse_address": { "name_shape_rows_address_contested": [ "ROW-016", "ROW-051" ], "name_shape_count": 2, "corpus_name_shape_rows": 145, "verdict": "case (b) — the board’s address line genuinely carries a business name for some registrants (raw DEN.TXT ba_address cited per row); the parser preserves both parts; no findings withdrawn; the affected findings’ reasons now carry the different sentence" } }, "authority_corpora": { "board": { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "rows": 4197, "delivery_path": "engagement-corpora/parsed-DEN.canonical.json", "raw_source": "engagement-corpora/DEN.TXT + board-drop-fetch-record.json (binding to the archived source)" }, "nppes": { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "rows": 1801, "delivery_path": "engagement-corpora/pool.canonical.json" }, "machinery": { "artifact": "engagement-corpora/engagement-findings.mjs", "note": "the adjudication machinery itself ships with the delivery — a buyer re-derives every finding from the shipped corpora with the shipped code (SOURCE-REPRO-1)" }, "coverage_evidence": { "artifact": "findings/coverage-evidence.json", "note": "every §4 absence claim carries the exact re-runnable lookup (key, corpus, digest, size, method, result)" } }, "sample_freeze": { "file": "../sample-freeze.json", "selected": 25, "frozen_at": "2026-09-13T14:38:33.536Z" }, "trust": { "key_id": "woc-engagement-mock-2026-09", "key_class": "MOCK-ENGAGEMENT — signs synthetic-engagement findings only; never a production signing key", "public_key": "-----BEGIN PUBLIC KEY-----\nMCowBQYDK2VwAyEAZSdmgudjC0VPUKx1ocRreZyhAJzrxOZYzRgkGJJ2GvE=\n-----END PUBLIC KEY-----\n" }, "honest_counts": { "rows": 25, "propositions": 100, "by_state": { "VERIFIED": 59, "CONTESTED": 23, "UNVERIFIABLE": 17, "STALE": 1 } }, "synthetic_demonstration": { "property": "none of the labeled bad fields was VERIFIED", "statement": "MOCK-2 (Tani 2026-09-14T06:44Z ruling item 8): each synthetic buyer row carries exactly ONE labeled defect on an otherwise valid fixture baseline, adjudicated against separately labeled SYNTHETIC FIXTURE authorities (fixture-authorities.json — never the pinned real corpora). Demonstrated property, stated exactly (R6-3 COVER-ASSERT-1, Tani 2026-09-14T18:08Z: the mechanism-detection claim is struck back to the demonstrated property): none of the labeled bad fields was VERIFIED; unaffected fields retained their supported outcomes; dependent fields blocked by a labeled defect are disclosed per row and never counted as detected defects. Never a mechanisms count.", "rows": [ { "row_id": "ROW-056", "defect_label": "LICENSE-ABSENCE — the licence number does not exist in the synthetic fixture roster; mechanism: §4 absence detection", "defect_field": "licence_number", "defect_detected_state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "defect_detected": true, "per_field_outcomes": { "licence_number": "UNVERIFIABLE", "provider_name": "UNVERIFIABLE", "npi": "VERIFIED", "practice_address": "UNVERIFIABLE" } }, { "row_id": "ROW-057", "defect_label": "NAME-MISMATCH — the buyer name differs from the fixture board licensee; mechanism: name-law CONTESTED detection", "defect_field": "provider_name", "defect_detected_state": "CONTESTED", "defect_detected": true, "per_field_outcomes": { "licence_number": "VERIFIED", "provider_name": "CONTESTED", "npi": "VERIFIED", "practice_address": "VERIFIED" } }, { "row_id": "ROW-058", "defect_label": "NPI-WRONG-PERSON — the NPI is another fixture provider's registration; mechanism: identity-linkage detection with dependent address adjudication blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 demonstrated)", "defect_field": "npi", "defect_detected_state": "CONTESTED", "defect_detected": true, "per_field_outcomes": { "licence_number": "VERIFIED", "provider_name": "CONTESTED", "npi": "CONTESTED", "practice_address": "UNVERIFIABLE" } }, { "row_id": "ROW-059", "defect_label": "ADDRESS-MISMATCH — the buyer address is a different street than the fixture board record; mechanism: address-law CONTESTED detection", "defect_field": "practice_address", "defect_detected_state": "CONTESTED", "defect_detected": true, "per_field_outcomes": { "licence_number": "VERIFIED", "provider_name": "VERIFIED", "npi": "VERIFIED", "practice_address": "CONTESTED" } }, { "row_id": "ROW-060", "defect_label": "LICENSE-EXPIRED — the fixture board record shows status Expired, expiresAt 2026-08-01 (before evaluation); mechanism: STALE detection", "defect_field": "licence_number", "defect_detected_state": "STALE", "defect_detected": true, "per_field_outcomes": { "licence_number": "STALE", "provider_name": "VERIFIED", "npi": "VERIFIED", "practice_address": "VERIFIED" } } ] }, "rows": [ { "row_id": "ROW-056", "record_class": "synthetic-provider-row", "synthetic": true, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Alexandra R. Exampleton, DDS", "licence_number": "9999999999", "npi": "1900000561", "practice_address": "101 Fixture Lane, Springfield, MO, 65801" }, "provenance": { "origin": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE — one labeled defect on an otherwise valid fixture baseline (MOCK-2, Tani 2026-09-14T06:44Z ruling item 8); authority records: fixture-authorities.json (labeled SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY, never the pinned real corpora)" }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": false, "evidence": "not evaluable (one authority record absent)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "§4 no board record for licence \"9999999999\" — the invented licence does not exist in the SYNTHETIC FIXTURE board roster (fixture-authorities.json)", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": null, "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "§4 no board record for licence \"9999999999\" — the invented licence does not exist in the SYNTHETIC FIXTURE board roster — the name cannot be checked against a person that does not exist in the fixture roster (fixture-authorities.json)", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": null, "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" }, { "field": "npi", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the asserted NPI exists in the pinned NPPES pool, and the NPPES-registered name matches the buyer-published name under the published name law. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — NPPES (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#nppes", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "ALEXANDRA EXAMPLETON", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1900000561", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "9000000561" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "§4 no board record for licence \"9999999999\" and no ground-truth address to check against (SYNTHETIC FIXTURE roster — fixture-authorities.json)", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": null, "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-057", "record_class": "synthetic-provider-row", "synthetic": true, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Margaret A. Totallydifferent, DDS", "licence_number": "9000000571", "npi": "1900000571", "practice_address": "202 Mockingbird Ct, Springfield, MO, 65804" }, "provenance": { "origin": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE — one labeled defect on an otherwise valid fixture baseline (MOCK-2, Tani 2026-09-14T06:44Z ruling item 8); authority records: fixture-authorities.json (labeled SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY, never the pinned real corpora)" }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": true, "evidence": "Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"9000000571\" = board licence \"9000000571\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30T00:00:00Z — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "9000000571", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30T00:00:00Z" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "the buyer-published name differs from the board roster name for this licence (board name \"Brandon K Samplefield\", buyer \"Margaret A. Totallydifferent, DDS\")", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "Brandon K Samplefield", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" }, { "field": "npi", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the asserted NPI exists in the pinned NPPES pool, and the NPPES-registered name matches the board roster name under the published name law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"9000000571\" = board licence \"9000000571\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — NPPES (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#nppes", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "BRANDON SAMPLEFIELD", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1900000571", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "9000000571" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published address matches the board roster address line as published under the v4 address law — and the NPPES practice location for the asserted NPI agrees under the v4 address law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"9000000571\" = board licence \"9000000571\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). Roles: board address_of_record vs NPPES practice location. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "202 Mockingbird Ct, Springfield, MO, 65804", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — NPPES (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#nppes", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "202 Mockingbird Ct, Springfield, MO, 65804", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1900000571", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-058", "record_class": "synthetic-provider-row", "synthetic": true, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Cassandra L. Testerville, DDS", "licence_number": "9000000581", "npi": "1900000571", "practice_address": "303 Placeholder Dr, Nixa, MO, 65714" }, "provenance": { "origin": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE — one labeled defect on an otherwise valid fixture baseline (MOCK-2, Tani 2026-09-14T06:44Z ruling item 8); authority records: fixture-authorities.json (labeled SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY, never the pinned real corpora)" }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": false, "evidence": "binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 9000000571; board licence \"9000000581\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30T00:00:00Z — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "9000000581", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30T00:00:00Z" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "CONTESTED", "finding_class": "identity-linkage", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the board record for licence \"9000000581\" names \"Cassandra L Testerville\"; the NPPES record for the asserted NPI \"1900000571\" names \"BRANDON SAMPLEFIELD\" — with no Tier-A identifier link the corpora do not establish that these are two distinct published persons (a name-presentation variant remains possible; the two-persons assertion is inadmissible without subject binding — LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z), and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 9000000571; board licence \"9000000581\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). The finding is actionable as an identity ticket; the dependent address adjudication is blocked. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "Cassandra L Testerville", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — NPPES (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#nppes", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "BRANDON SAMPLEFIELD", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1900000571", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "9000000571" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" }, { "field": "npi", "state": "CONTESTED", "finding_class": "identity-linkage", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the asserted NPI \"1900000571\" is registered in NPPES to \"BRANDON SAMPLEFIELD\" (NPPES MO taxonomy license \"9000000571\"), while the board licence \"9000000581\" names \"Cassandra L Testerville\" — no identifier link establishes the NPI record as the same subject, and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 9000000571; board licence \"9000000581\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). This is the finding class a buyer pays for: an actionable identity ticket, never an auto-substituted identifier. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — NPPES (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#nppes", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "BRANDON SAMPLEFIELD", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1900000571", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "9000000571" }, { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "Cassandra L Testerville", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 9000000571; board licence \"9000000581\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality); dependent address adjudication is blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 (a)) temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "303 Placeholder Dr, Nixa, MO, 65714", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — NPPES (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#nppes", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "202 Mockingbird Ct, Springfield, MO, 65804", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1900000571", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-059", "record_class": "synthetic-provider-row", "synthetic": true, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Derrick M. Dummyworth, DDS", "licence_number": "9000000591", "npi": "1900000591", "practice_address": "999 Wrong Street, Springfield, MO, 65801" }, "provenance": { "origin": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE — one labeled defect on an otherwise valid fixture baseline (MOCK-2, Tani 2026-09-14T06:44Z ruling item 8); authority records: fixture-authorities.json (labeled SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY, never the pinned real corpora)" }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": true, "evidence": "Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"9000000591\" = board licence \"9000000591\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30T00:00:00Z — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "9000000591", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30T00:00:00Z" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published name matches the board roster name under the published name law, and the NPPES record for the asserted NPI names the same person (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"9000000591\" = board licence \"9000000591\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "Derrick M Dummyworth", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — NPPES (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#nppes", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "DERRICK DUMMYWORTH", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1900000591", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" }, { "field": "npi", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the asserted NPI exists in the pinned NPPES pool, and the NPPES-registered name matches the board roster name under the published name law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"9000000591\" = board licence \"9000000591\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — NPPES (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#nppes", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "DERRICK DUMMYWORTH", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1900000591", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "9000000591" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "the buyer-published address differs from the board roster address for this licence (ZIP5 65801 vs 65721). Roles: buyer published practice location vs board address_of_record. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "404 Specimen Ave, Ozark, MO, 65721", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — NPPES (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#nppes", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "404 Specimen Ave, Ozark, MO, 65721", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1900000591", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-060", "record_class": "synthetic-provider-row", "synthetic": true, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Elena V. Paradigmquist, DDS", "licence_number": "9000000601", "npi": "1900000601", "practice_address": "505 Simulated Blvd, Republic, MO, 65619" }, "provenance": { "origin": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE — one labeled defect on an otherwise valid fixture baseline (MOCK-2, Tani 2026-09-14T06:44Z ruling item 8); authority records: fixture-authorities.json (labeled SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY, never the pinned real corpora)" }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": true, "evidence": "Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"9000000601\" = board licence \"9000000601\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "STALE", "reason": "board licence expired 2026-08-01T00:00:00Z (before evaluation 2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z)", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "9000000601", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Expired", "expires_at": "2026-08-01T00:00:00Z" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published name matches the board roster name under the published name law, and the NPPES record for the asserted NPI names the same person (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"9000000601\" = board licence \"9000000601\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "Elena V Paradigmquist", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — NPPES (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#nppes", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "ELENA PARADIGMQUIST", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1900000601", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" }, { "field": "npi", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the asserted NPI exists in the pinned NPPES pool, and the NPPES-registered name matches the board roster name under the published name law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"9000000601\" = board licence \"9000000601\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — NPPES (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#nppes", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "ELENA PARADIGMQUIST", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1900000601", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "9000000601" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published address matches the board roster address line as published under the v4 address law — and the NPPES practice location for the asserted NPI agrees under the v4 address law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"9000000601\" = board licence \"9000000601\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). Roles: board address_of_record vs NPPES practice location. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — board (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#board", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "505 Simulated Blvd, Republic, MO, 65619", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE AUTHORITY — NPPES (invented records for the mock demonstration; never the pinned real corpora)", "artifact": "fixture-authorities.json#nppes", "artifact_sha256": "4810ff3395bd34b5e3690a5cba25cc6432b43636bf38d68c56ec6cfc0cbec2e3", "value": "505 Simulated Blvd, Republic, MO, 65619", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1900000601", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." }, "fixture_context": "SYNTHETIC FIXTURE ROW — every board-roster/NPPES-pool reference in this reason names the labeled fixture authorities (fixture-authorities.json), never the pinned real corpora; the labeled defect and the demonstrated property are stated in synthetic_demonstration" } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-021", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Darrell W Hedrick", "licence_number": "014903", "npi": "1760510002", "practice_address": "2001 Laquesta Dr, Neosho, MO, 64850" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-045", "join_evidence": "NPPES taxonomy row carries MO license \"14903\" (taxonomy 1223G0001X); board license_number \"014903\"; join key: license string match (after stripping leading zeros)." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": true, "evidence": "Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"14903\" = board licence \"014903\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "014903", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published name matches the board roster name under the published name law, and the NPPES record for the asserted NPI names the same person (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"14903\" = board licence \"014903\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Darrell W Hedrick", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "DARRELL HEDRICK", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1760510002", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the asserted NPI exists in the pinned NPPES pool, and the NPPES-registered name matches the board roster name under the published name law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"14903\" = board licence \"014903\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "DARRELL HEDRICK", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1760510002", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "14903" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published address matches the board roster address line as published under the v4 address law — and the NPPES practice location for the asserted NPI agrees under the v4 address law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"14903\" = board licence \"014903\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). Roles: board address_of_record vs NPPES practice location. Wave-offs: state-component alias expansion (MO≡MISSOURI, state field only — same state, not a directory defect; STATE-ALIAS-1). Wave-offs: state-component alias expansion (MISSOURI≡MO, state field only — same state, not a directory defect; STATE-ALIAS-1). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2001 Laquesta Dr, Neosho, Missouri, 64850", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "2001 LA QUESTA DR, NEOSHO, MO, 64850", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1760510002", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-028", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Douglas A Carano", "licence_number": "014204", "npi": "1699867838", "practice_address": "7056 Highway BB, Cedar Hill, MO, 63016" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-074", "join_evidence": "Near-miss names: board \"Douglas A Carano\" vs NPPES \"DOUGLAS CARANO\" — same last name, same first initial, not identical; no licence evidence." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": true, "evidence": "Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"MO14204\" = board licence \"014204\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "014204", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published name matches the board roster name under the published name law, and the NPPES record for the asserted NPI names the same person (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"MO14204\" = board licence \"014204\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Douglas A Carano", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "DOUGLAS CARANO", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1699867838", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the asserted NPI exists in the pinned NPPES pool, and the NPPES-registered name matches the board roster name under the published name law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"MO14204\" = board licence \"014204\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "DOUGLAS CARANO", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1699867838", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "MO14204" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published address matches the board roster address line as published under the v4 address law — and the NPPES practice location for the asserted NPI agrees under the v4 address law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"MO14204\" = board licence \"014204\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). Roles: board address_of_record vs NPPES practice location. Wave-offs: state-component alias expansion (MO≡MISSOURI, state field only — same state, not a directory defect; STATE-ALIAS-1). Wave-offs: state-component alias expansion (MISSOURI≡MO, state field only — same state, not a directory defect; STATE-ALIAS-1). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "7056 Highway BB, Cedar Hill, Missouri, 63016", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "7056 HIGHWAY BB, CEDAR HILL, MO, 63016", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1699867838", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-016", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Kelsey Elizabeth Hayes", "licence_number": "2017017505", "npi": "1588194369", "practice_address": "Elevate Dental Studio, Springfield, MO, 65810" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-131", "join_evidence": "NPPES taxonomy row carries MO license \"2017017505\" (taxonomy 122300000X); board license_number \"2017017505\"; join key: license string match (exact, after normalization)." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": true, "evidence": "Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2017017505\" = board licence \"2017017505\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2017017505", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published name matches the board roster name under the published name law, and the NPPES record for the asserted NPI names the same person (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2017017505\" = board licence \"2017017505\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Kelsey Elizabeth Hayes", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "KELSEY HAYES", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1588194369", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the asserted NPI exists in the pinned NPPES pool, and the NPPES-registered name matches the board roster name under the published name law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2017017505\" = board licence \"2017017505\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "KELSEY HAYES", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1588194369", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "2017017505" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "the board publishes a practice name where the buyer publishes a partial line (name-shape publication — board line: \"Elevate Dental Studio\", street \"304 W Weaver Road\"): the buyer-published address differs from the board line as published (street line \"Elevate Dental Studio\" vs \"Elevate Dental Studio, 304 W Weaver Road\"). Roles: buyer published practice location vs board address_of_record. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Elevate Dental Studio, 304 W Weaver Road, Springfield, Missouri, 65810", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "name_shape_publication": true }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "4350 S NATIONAL AVE STE C112, SPRINGFIELD, MO, 65810", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1588194369", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-020", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Kristen Kimberly Schreiner", "licence_number": "2001015390", "npi": "1154164747", "practice_address": "485 SW Ward Rd, Lees Summit, MO, 64081" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-143", "join_evidence": "Shared address: board \"485 SW Ward Rd, Lees Summit, MO, 64081\" vs NPPES practice location \"485 SW WARD RD, LEES SUMMIT, MO, 64081\" — normalized street+zip match; names differ." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": false, "evidence": "binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 2024019627; board licence \"2001015390\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2001015390", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "CONTESTED", "finding_class": "identity-linkage", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the board record for licence \"2001015390\" names \"Kristen Kimberly Schreiner\"; the NPPES record for the asserted NPI \"1154164747\" names \"KENDALL CLINE\" — with no Tier-A identifier link the corpora do not establish that these are two distinct published persons (a name-presentation variant remains possible; the two-persons assertion is inadmissible without subject binding — LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z), and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 2024019627; board licence \"2001015390\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). The finding is actionable as an identity ticket; the dependent address adjudication is blocked. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Kristen Kimberly Schreiner", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "KENDALL CLINE", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1154164747", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "2024019627" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "CONTESTED", "finding_class": "identity-linkage", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the asserted NPI \"1154164747\" is registered in NPPES to \"KENDALL CLINE\" (NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2024019627\"), while the board licence \"2001015390\" names \"Kristen Kimberly Schreiner\" — no identifier link establishes the NPI record as the same subject, and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 2024019627; board licence \"2001015390\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). This is the finding class a buyer pays for: an actionable identity ticket, never an auto-substituted identifier. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "KENDALL CLINE", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1154164747", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "2024019627" }, { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Kristen Kimberly Schreiner", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 2024019627; board licence \"2001015390\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality); dependent address adjudication is blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 (a)) Both preserved readings AGREE after the v4 normalizations — the unresolved question is subject binding, not the address. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "485 SW Ward Rd, Lees Summit, Missouri, 64081", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "485 SW WARD RD, LEES SUMMIT, MO, 64081", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1154164747", "entity_type": "individual" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "485 SW WARD RD, LEES SUMMIT, MO, 64081", "role": "mailing", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1154164747", "entity_type": "individual", "context": "mailing address preserved as context — never contradiction fodder" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-033", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Matthew Theriac", "licence_number": "015187", "npi": "1831269158", "practice_address": "905 Jackson St, Macon, MO, 63552" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-177", "join_evidence": "Normalized names both \"MATTHEW THERIAC\" (board name \"Matthew Theriac\", NPPES name \"MATTHEW THERIAC\"); no licence evidence on the NPPES side (no MO taxonomy license field to compare)." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": true, "evidence": "Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"DEO 15187\" = board licence \"015187\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "015187", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published name matches the board roster name under the published name law, and the NPPES record for the asserted NPI names the same person (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"DEO 15187\" = board licence \"015187\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Matthew Theriac", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "MATTHEW THERIAC", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1831269158", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the asserted NPI exists in the pinned NPPES pool, and the NPPES-registered name matches the board roster name under the published name law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"DEO 15187\" = board licence \"015187\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "MATTHEW THERIAC", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1831269158", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "DEO 15187" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published address matches the board roster address line as published under the v4 address law — and the NPPES practice location for the asserted NPI agrees under the v4 address law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"DEO 15187\" = board licence \"015187\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). Roles: board address_of_record vs NPPES practice location. Wave-offs: state-component alias expansion (MO≡MISSOURI, state field only — same state, not a directory defect; STATE-ALIAS-1). Wave-offs: state-component alias expansion (MISSOURI≡MO, state field only — same state, not a directory defect; STATE-ALIAS-1). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "905 Jackson St, Macon, Missouri, 63552", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "905 JACKSON ST, MACON, MO, 63552", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1831269158", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-010", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Jeffrey P Smith", "licence_number": "013930", "npi": "1033089750", "practice_address": "3101 Droste Rd, St Charles, MO, 63301" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-117", "join_evidence": "Shared address: board \"3101 Droste Rd, St Charles, MO, 63301\" vs NPPES practice location \"3101 DROSTE RD, SAINT CHARLES, MO, 63301\" — normalized street+zip match; names differ." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": false, "evidence": "binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"013930\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "013930", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "CONTESTED", "finding_class": "npi-entity-role", "reason": "NPI entity-role finding (NPI-ROLE-1): the asserted NPI \"1033089750\" is registered in NPPES as an ORGANIZATION (\"DANIELLE WOLFE DDS LLC\", authorized official DANIELLE WOLFE) while the buyer row names an individual practitioner (\"Jeffrey P Smith\", board licensee \"Jeffrey P Smith\") — RULED (Tani 2026-09-14T15:15Z): the buyer's NPI field denotes the individual practitioner (NPPES entity type 1) — an organization NPI (entity type 2) in that field is erroneous against the ruled field contract. This is a ROLE finding, never a name mismatch; binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"013930\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Jeffrey P Smith", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "DANIELLE WOLFE DDS LLC", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1033089750", "entity_type": "organization", "authorized_official": "DANIELLE WOLFE" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "CONTESTED", "finding_class": "npi-entity-role", "reason": "NPI entity-role finding (NPI-ROLE-1): the asserted NPI \"1033089750\" is an ORGANIZATION-entity registration (\"DANIELLE WOLFE DDS LLC\", authorized official DANIELLE WOLFE) while the buyer row names the individual practitioner \"Jeffrey P Smith\" — an individual name paired with the organization's NPI is a ROLE finding, never a name mismatch; RULED (Tani 2026-09-14T15:15Z): the buyer's NPI field denotes the individual practitioner (NPPES entity type 1) — an organization NPI (entity type 2) in that field is erroneous against the ruled field contract. Never auto-substitute an identifier. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "DANIELLE WOLFE DDS LLC", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1033089750", "entity_type": "organization", "authorized_official": "DANIELLE WOLFE" }, { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Jeffrey P Smith", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"013930\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality); dependent address adjudication is blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 (a)) Both preserved readings AGREE after the v4 normalizations — the unresolved question is subject binding, not the address. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "3101 Droste Rd, St Charles, Missouri, 63301", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "3101 DROSTE RD, SAINT CHARLES, MO, 63301", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1033089750", "entity_type": "organization" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "1353 W GATEWAY HTS, SAINT LOUIS, MO, 63144", "role": "mailing", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1033089750", "entity_type": "organization", "context": "mailing address preserved as context — never contradiction fodder" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-019", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Kevin Russell Duniven", "licence_number": "2012015445", "npi": "1316207475", "practice_address": "11426 Gravois Rd Ste 202, Saint Louis, MO, 63126" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-099", "join_evidence": "NPPES taxonomy row carries MO license \"2012015445\" (taxonomy 1223G0001X); board license_number \"2012015445\"; join key: license string match (exact, after normalization)." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": true, "evidence": "Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2012015445\" = board licence \"2012015445\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2012015445", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published name matches the board roster name under the published name law, and the NPPES record for the asserted NPI names the same person (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2012015445\" = board licence \"2012015445\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Kevin Russell Duniven", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "KEVIN DUNIVEN", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1316207475", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the asserted NPI exists in the pinned NPPES pool, and the NPPES-registered name matches the board roster name under the published name law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2012015445\" = board licence \"2012015445\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "KEVIN DUNIVEN", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1316207475", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "2012015445" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published address matches the board roster address line as published under the v4 address law — and the NPPES practice location for the asserted NPI agrees under the v4 address law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2012015445\" = board licence \"2012015445\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). Roles: board address_of_record vs NPPES practice location. Wave-offs: state-component alias expansion (MO≡MISSOURI, state field only — same state, not a directory defect; STATE-ALIAS-1). Wave-offs: state-component alias expansion (MISSOURI≡MO, state field only — same state, not a directory defect; STATE-ALIAS-1); unit-omission wave-off — unit on one side only: \"STE 202\" vs \"∅\"; unit omission is not a conflict (ADJUDICATION-2 (d)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "11426 Gravois Rd Ste 202, Saint Louis, Missouri, 63126", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "11426 GRAVOIS RD, SAINT LOUIS, MO, 63126", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1316207475", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-051", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Benjamin Ted Gallion", "licence_number": "2015016955", "npi": "1770964116", "practice_address": "Jump Dental LLC, Bolivar, MO, 65613" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-095", "join_evidence": "NPPES taxonomy row carries MO license \"2015016955\" (taxonomy 122300000X); board license_number \"2015016955\"; join key: license string match (exact, after normalization)." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": true, "evidence": "Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2015016955\" = board licence \"2015016955\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2015016955", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published name matches the board roster name under the published name law, and the NPPES record for the asserted NPI names the same person (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2015016955\" = board licence \"2015016955\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Benjamin Ted Gallion", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "BENJAMIN GALLION", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1770964116", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the asserted NPI exists in the pinned NPPES pool, and the NPPES-registered name matches the board roster name under the published name law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2015016955\" = board licence \"2015016955\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "BENJAMIN GALLION", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1770964116", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "2015016955" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "the board publishes a practice name where the buyer publishes a partial line (name-shape publication — board line: \"Jump Dental LLC\", street \"1300 N. Oakland Avenue, Ste. C\"): the buyer-published address differs from the board line as published (street line \"Jump Dental LLC\" vs \"Jump Dental LLC, 1300 N. Oakland Avenue, Ste. C\"). Roles: buyer published practice location vs board address_of_record. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Jump Dental LLC, 1300 N. Oakland Avenue, Ste. C, Bolivar, Missouri, 65613", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "name_shape_publication": true }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "1402 S ELLIOTT AVE STE A, AURORA, MO, 65605", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1770964116", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-023", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Jerell James Wilson", "licence_number": "2012015521", "npi": "1538270384", "practice_address": "180 Shortleaf Pine Drive, Saint Charles, MO, 63304" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-038", "join_evidence": "Near-miss names: board \"Jerell James Wilson\" vs NPPES \"JAMES WILSON\" — same last name, same first initial, not identical; no licence evidence." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": false, "evidence": "binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 12558; board licence \"2012015521\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2012015521", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "CONTESTED", "finding_class": "identity-linkage", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the board record for licence \"2012015521\" names \"Jerell James Wilson\"; the NPPES record for the asserted NPI \"1538270384\" names \"JAMES WILSON\" — with no Tier-A identifier link the corpora do not establish that these are two distinct published persons (a name-presentation variant remains possible; the two-persons assertion is inadmissible without subject binding — LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z), and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 12558; board licence \"2012015521\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). The finding is actionable as an identity ticket; the dependent address adjudication is blocked. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Jerell James Wilson", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "JAMES WILSON", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1538270384", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "12558" } ], "ticket": { "note": "fresh exact-identifier lookups on both sides, cited with URL, acquisition time and SHA-256 — observations of 2026-09-14 live CMS NPPES queries, not the pinned 2026-09-09 pool; never an auto-substituted identifier", "fresh_lookups": [ { "direction": "NPI→name/license", "url": "https://npiregistry.cms.hhs.gov/api/?number=1538270384&version=2.1", "acquired_at": "2026-09-14T06:05:44Z", "sha256": "47f30e33376524075ffcce5c633bbf6cf5c39fe7100f137fa343c3e3c97d26b6", "result": { "npi": "1538270384", "name": "JAMES A WILSON", "mo_taxonomy_license": "12558 (Dentist, General Practice)" } }, { "direction": "license→NPI (exact-name query)", "url": "https://npiregistry.cms.hhs.gov/api/?first_name=Jerell&last_name=Wilson&version=2.1", "acquired_at": "2026-09-14T06:07:54Z", "sha256": "881f1e85d573b06616060cb7227b34b66d3111b398b7a17b0f3f9ee926ace70c", "result": { "npi": "1770844359", "name": "JERELL WILSON", "mo_taxonomy_license": "2012015521 (Dentist) — EXACT MATCH to the buyer-published licence" } } ] }, "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "CONTESTED", "finding_class": "identity-linkage", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the asserted NPI \"1538270384\" is registered in NPPES to \"JAMES WILSON\" (NPPES MO taxonomy license \"12558\"), while the board licence \"2012015521\" names \"Jerell James Wilson\" — no identifier link establishes the NPI record as the same subject, and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 12558; board licence \"2012015521\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). This is the finding class a buyer pays for: an actionable identity ticket, never an auto-substituted identifier. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "JAMES WILSON", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1538270384", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "12558" }, { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Jerell James Wilson", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ], "ticket": { "note": "fresh exact-identifier lookups on both sides, cited with URL, acquisition time and SHA-256 — observations of 2026-09-14 live CMS NPPES queries, not the pinned 2026-09-09 pool; never an auto-substituted identifier", "fresh_lookups": [ { "direction": "NPI→name/license", "url": "https://npiregistry.cms.hhs.gov/api/?number=1538270384&version=2.1", "acquired_at": "2026-09-14T06:05:44Z", "sha256": "47f30e33376524075ffcce5c633bbf6cf5c39fe7100f137fa343c3e3c97d26b6", "result": { "npi": "1538270384", "name": "JAMES A WILSON", "mo_taxonomy_license": "12558 (Dentist, General Practice)" } }, { "direction": "license→NPI (exact-name query)", "url": "https://npiregistry.cms.hhs.gov/api/?first_name=Jerell&last_name=Wilson&version=2.1", "acquired_at": "2026-09-14T06:07:54Z", "sha256": "881f1e85d573b06616060cb7227b34b66d3111b398b7a17b0f3f9ee926ace70c", "result": { "npi": "1770844359", "name": "JERELL WILSON", "mo_taxonomy_license": "2012015521 (Dentist) — EXACT MATCH to the buyer-published licence" } } ] }, "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 12558; board licence \"2012015521\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality); dependent address adjudication is blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 (a)) temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "180 Shortleaf Pine Drive, Saint Charles, Missouri, 63304", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "509 S MISSOURI ST, MACON, MO, 63552", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1538270384", "entity_type": "individual" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "509 S MISSOURI ST, MACON, MO, 63552", "role": "mailing", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1538270384", "entity_type": "individual", "context": "mailing address preserved as context — never contradiction fodder" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-001", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Courtney Nicole Bishop", "licence_number": "2024025025", "npi": "1891533618", "practice_address": "8500 Maryland Ave, Clayton, MO, 63124" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-098", "join_evidence": "NPPES taxonomy row carries MO license \"2024025025\" (taxonomy 122300000X); board license_number \"2024025025\"; join key: license string match (exact, after normalization)." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": true, "evidence": "Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2024025025\" = board licence \"2024025025\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2024025025", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published name matches the board roster name under the published name law, and the NPPES record for the asserted NPI names the same person (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2024025025\" = board licence \"2024025025\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Courtney Nicole Bishop", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "COURTNEY BISHOP", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1891533618", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the asserted NPI exists in the pinned NPPES pool, and the NPPES-registered name matches the board roster name under the published name law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2024025025\" = board licence \"2024025025\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "COURTNEY BISHOP", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1891533618", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "2024025025" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "role comparability not established (R8-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z): the delivered NPPES object publishes the board-like address under the MAILING role (\"8500 MARYLAND AVE APT 507, CLAYTON, MO, 63124\"), while its practice location differs from the board address of record (ZIP5 63124 vs 63104) — a NPPES mailing address is never contradiction fodder and role mismatch is not a contradiction (ADJUDICATION-2 (b)); the comparison the contradiction would need is role-mismatched, so the comparison is refused and both readings are preserved. Roles: board address_of_record vs NPPES practice location vs NPPES mailing (context). Subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2024025025\" = board licence \"2024025025\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "8500 Maryland Ave, Apt 507, Clayton, Missouri, 63124", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "2229 S 12TH ST, SAINT LOUIS, MO, 63104", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1891533618", "entity_type": "individual" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "8500 MARYLAND AVE APT 507, CLAYTON, MO, 63124", "role": "mailing", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1891533618", "entity_type": "individual", "context": "the board-like address as published by NPPES — under the mailing role; never contradiction fodder" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-007", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Todd Douglas Anderson", "licence_number": "2005000386", "npi": "1255450763", "practice_address": "3649 S Suburban Ave, Springfield, MO, 65807" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-179", "join_evidence": "NPPES taxonomy row carries MO license \"2005000386\" (taxonomy 1223G0001X); board license_number \"2005000386\"; join key: license string match (exact, after normalization)." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": true, "evidence": "Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2005000386\" = board licence \"2005000386\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2005000386", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published name matches the board roster name under the published name law, and the NPPES record for the asserted NPI names the same person (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2005000386\" = board licence \"2005000386\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Todd Douglas Anderson", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "TODD ANDERSON", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1255450763", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the asserted NPI exists in the pinned NPPES pool, and the NPPES-registered name matches the board roster name under the published name law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2005000386\" = board licence \"2005000386\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "TODD ANDERSON", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1255450763", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "2005000386" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "the buyer address matches the board roster, but the NPPES practice location for the asserted NPI differs — the two authorities disagree (ZIP5 65807 vs 65803). Subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2005000386\" = board licence \"2005000386\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1). Roles: board address_of_record vs NPPES practice location. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "3649 S Suburban Ave, Springfield, Missouri, 65807", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "2105 W KEARNEY ST, SPRINGFIELD, MO, 65803", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1255450763", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-012", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Marzieh Currimbhoy", "licence_number": "2024037183", "npi": "1124708391", "practice_address": "2712 Grover Crossing Drive, Wildwood, MO, 63040" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-174", "join_evidence": "Normalized names both \"MARZIEH CURRIMBHOY\" (board name \"Marzieh Currimbhoy\", NPPES name \"MARZIEH CURRIMBHOY\"); no licence evidence on the NPPES side (no MO taxonomy license field to compare)." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": false, "evidence": "binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2024037183\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2024037183", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2024037183\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). ADJUDICATION-2 (a) requires Tier-A identifier equality before any cross-authority comparison is asserted; the comparison is blocked and both readings are preserved. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Marzieh Currimbhoy", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "MARZIEH CURRIMBHOY", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1124708391", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2024037183\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). ADJUDICATION-2 (a) requires Tier-A identifier equality before any cross-authority comparison is asserted; the comparison is blocked and both readings are preserved. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Marzieh Currimbhoy", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "MARZIEH CURRIMBHOY", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1124708391", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2024037183\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality); dependent address adjudication is blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 (a)) Both preserved readings AGREE after the v4 normalizations — the unresolved question is subject binding, not the address. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2712 Grover Crossing Drive, Wildwood, Missouri, 63040", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "2712 GROVER CROSSING DR, WILDWOOD, MO, 63040", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1124708391", "entity_type": "individual" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "2712 GROVER CROSSING DR, WILDWOOD, MO, 63040", "role": "mailing", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1124708391", "entity_type": "individual", "context": "mailing address preserved as context — never contradiction fodder" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-052", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Nathan Dean Hartman", "licence_number": "2008014681", "npi": "1487139754", "practice_address": "2690 Gravois Rd, High Ridge, MO, 63049" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-086", "join_evidence": "Shared address: board \"2690 Gravois Rd, High Ridge, MO, 63049\" vs NPPES practice location \"2690 GRAVOIS RD, HIGH RIDGE, MO, 63049\" — normalized street+zip match; names differ." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": false, "evidence": "binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2008014681\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2008014681", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "CONTESTED", "finding_class": "npi-entity-role", "reason": "NPI entity-role finding (NPI-ROLE-1): the asserted NPI \"1487139754\" is registered in NPPES as an ORGANIZATION (\"SLEEP WELL STL\", authorized official NATHAN HARTMAN) while the buyer row names an individual practitioner (\"Nathan Dean Hartman\", board licensee \"Nathan Dean Hartman\") — RULED (Tani 2026-09-14T15:15Z): the buyer's NPI field denotes the individual practitioner (NPPES entity type 1) — an organization NPI (entity type 2) in that field is erroneous against the ruled field contract. This is a ROLE finding, never a name mismatch; binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2008014681\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Nathan Dean Hartman", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "SLEEP WELL STL", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1487139754", "entity_type": "organization", "authorized_official": "NATHAN HARTMAN" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "CONTESTED", "finding_class": "npi-entity-role", "reason": "NPI entity-role finding (NPI-ROLE-1): the asserted NPI \"1487139754\" is an ORGANIZATION-entity registration (\"SLEEP WELL STL\", authorized official NATHAN HARTMAN) while the buyer row names the individual practitioner \"Nathan Dean Hartman\" — an individual name paired with the organization's NPI is a ROLE finding, never a name mismatch; RULED (Tani 2026-09-14T15:15Z): the buyer's NPI field denotes the individual practitioner (NPPES entity type 1) — an organization NPI (entity type 2) in that field is erroneous against the ruled field contract. Never auto-substitute an identifier. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "SLEEP WELL STL", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1487139754", "entity_type": "organization", "authorized_official": "NATHAN HARTMAN" }, { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Nathan Dean Hartman", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2008014681\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality); dependent address adjudication is blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 (a)) Both preserved readings AGREE after the v4 normalizations — the unresolved question is subject binding, not the address. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2690 Gravois Rd, High Ridge, Missouri, 63049", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "2690 GRAVOIS RD, HIGH RIDGE, MO, 63049", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1487139754", "entity_type": "organization" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "2690 GRAVOIS RD, HIGH RIDGE, MO, 63049", "role": "mailing", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1487139754", "entity_type": "organization", "context": "mailing address preserved as context — never contradiction fodder" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-022", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "London Mason Bales", "licence_number": "2025019620", "npi": "1952090789", "practice_address": "18025 Kent Circle, Independence, MO, 64057" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-139", "join_evidence": "NPPES taxonomy row carries MO license \"2025019620\" (taxonomy 1223G0001X); board license_number \"2025019620\"; join key: license string match (exact, after normalization)." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": true, "evidence": "Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2025019620\" = board licence \"2025019620\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2025019620", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published name matches the board roster name under the published name law, and the NPPES record for the asserted NPI names the same person (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2025019620\" = board licence \"2025019620\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "London Mason Bales", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "LONDON BALES", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1952090789", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the asserted NPI exists in the pinned NPPES pool, and the NPPES-registered name matches the board roster name under the published name law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2025019620\" = board licence \"2025019620\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "LONDON BALES", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1952090789", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "2025019620" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "the buyer address matches the board roster, but the NPPES practice location for the asserted NPI differs — the two authorities disagree (ZIP5 64057 vs 64633). Subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2025019620\" = board licence \"2025019620\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1). Roles: board address_of_record vs NPPES practice location. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "18025 Kent Circle, Independence, Missouri, 64057", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "718 HARVEST HILLS DR, CARROLLTON, MO, 64633", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1952090789", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-055", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "David L Merello", "licence_number": "012663", "npi": "1164455234", "practice_address": "2154 SW Forestpark Ct, Lees Summit, MO, 64081" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-081", "join_evidence": "Near-miss names: board \"David L Merello\" vs NPPES \"DAVID MERELLO\" — same last name, same first initial, not identical; no licence evidence." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": true, "evidence": "Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"MO 12663\" = board licence \"012663\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "012663", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published name matches the board roster name under the published name law, and the NPPES record for the asserted NPI names the same person (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"MO 12663\" = board licence \"012663\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "David L Merello", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "DAVID MERELLO", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1164455234", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the asserted NPI exists in the pinned NPPES pool, and the NPPES-registered name matches the board roster name under the published name law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"MO 12663\" = board licence \"012663\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "DAVID MERELLO", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1164455234", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "MO 12663" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "the buyer address matches the board roster, but the NPPES practice location for the asserted NPI differs — the two authorities disagree (ZIP5 64081 vs 64030). Subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"MO 12663\" = board licence \"012663\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1). Roles: board address_of_record vs NPPES practice location. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2154 SW Forestpark Ct, Lees Summit, Missouri, 64081", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "12508 WINCHESTER AVE, GRANDVIEW, MO, 64030", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1164455234", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-034", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Kathleen Elizabeth Cooper", "licence_number": "2013044561", "npi": "1538420401", "practice_address": "12600 Sagamoore Rd, Leawood, MO, 66209" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-193", "join_evidence": "NPPES taxonomy row carries MO license \"2013044561\" (taxonomy 122300000X); board license_number \"2013044561\"; join key: license string match (exact, after normalization)." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": true, "evidence": "Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2013044561\" = board licence \"2013044561\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2013044561", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published name matches the board roster name under the published name law, and the NPPES record for the asserted NPI names the same person (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2013044561\" = board licence \"2013044561\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Kathleen Elizabeth Cooper", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "KATHLEEN COOPER", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1538420401", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the asserted NPI exists in the pinned NPPES pool, and the NPPES-registered name matches the board roster name under the published name law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2013044561\" = board licence \"2013044561\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "KATHLEEN COOPER", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1538420401", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "2013044561" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "cross-state mismatch (CROSS-STATE-1, R7-8 rerun — Tani 2026-09-15T00:33Z): EXTRACT-1 history — our parser produced the \"MO\" — the board publishes Leawood, KANSAS 66209 (ba_state \"Kansas\" in the raw row); the parsed canonical carries state: None for this licence and the reading renderer defaulted to MO — an extraction defect, never a board publication — the defect was OURS (SERVICE-DEBT-1); the parser fix landed and THIS rerun, at our expense, emits the finding the blocked comparison owed: the buyer publishes the practice in Missouri while the board's address of record is out-of-state (state MO vs KANSAS) temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "12600 Sagamoore Rd, Leawood, Kansas, 66209", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "parsed_render": "the parser-fixed rendering — the board row’s true state preserved (EXTRACT-1 resolved)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "103 CONGRESS ST, BELTON, MO, 64012", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1538420401", "entity_type": "individual" }, { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry — RAW SOURCE", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10, raw line (shipped: engagement-corpora/DEN.TXT)", "value": "Kathleen Elizabeth Cooper — ba_address \"12600 Sagamoore Rd\", ba_city \"Leawood\", ba_state \"Kansas\", ba_zip \"66209\", ba_cnty \"Unknown/Out of State\" (raw DEN.TXT line 67, shipped: engagement-corpora/DEN.TXT)" } ], "source_reading": { "raw_line": 67, "raw": "Kathleen Elizabeth Cooper — ba_address \"12600 Sagamoore Rd\", ba_city \"Leawood\", ba_state \"Kansas\", ba_zip \"66209\", ba_cnty \"Unknown/Out of State\" (raw DEN.TXT line 67, shipped: engagement-corpora/DEN.TXT)", "verdict": "our parser produced the \"MO\" — the board publishes Leawood, KANSAS 66209 (ba_state \"Kansas\" in the raw row); the parsed canonical carries state: None for this licence and the reading renderer defaulted to MO — an extraction defect, never a board publication" }, "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-030", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Umair Bajwa", "licence_number": "2026013800", "npi": "1336870823", "practice_address": "1353 Westhampton Woods Ct, Chesterfield, MO, 63005" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-068", "join_evidence": "Normalized names both \"UMAIR BAJWA\" (board name \"Umair Bajwa\", NPPES name \"UMAIR BAJWA\"); no licence evidence on the NPPES side (no MO taxonomy license field to compare)." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": false, "evidence": "binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2026013800\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2026013800", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2026013800\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). ADJUDICATION-2 (a) requires Tier-A identifier equality before any cross-authority comparison is asserted; the comparison is blocked and both readings are preserved. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Umair Bajwa", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "UMAIR BAJWA", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1336870823", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2026013800\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). ADJUDICATION-2 (a) requires Tier-A identifier equality before any cross-authority comparison is asserted; the comparison is blocked and both readings are preserved. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Umair Bajwa", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "UMAIR BAJWA", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1336870823", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: none; board licence \"2026013800\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality); dependent address adjudication is blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 (a)) temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "1353 Westhampton Woods Ct, Chesterfield, Missouri, 63005", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "2406 N BROAD ST, COLMAR, PA, 18915", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1336870823", "entity_type": "individual" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "1353 WESTHAMPTON WOODS CT, WILDWOOD, MO, 63005", "role": "mailing", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1336870823", "entity_type": "individual", "context": "mailing address preserved as context — never contradiction fodder" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-039", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Craig M Alexander", "licence_number": "014664", "npi": "1073545752", "practice_address": "450 S Parker, Olathe, MO, 66061" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-055", "join_evidence": "Near-miss names: board \"Craig M Alexander\" vs NPPES \"CURTIS ALEXANDER\" — same last name, same first initial, not identical; no licence evidence." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": false, "evidence": "binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 014891; board licence \"014664\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "014664", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "CONTESTED", "finding_class": "identity-linkage", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the board record for licence \"014664\" names \"Craig M Alexander\"; the NPPES record for the asserted NPI \"1073545752\" names \"CURTIS ALEXANDER\" — with no Tier-A identifier link the corpora do not establish that these are two distinct published persons (a name-presentation variant remains possible; the two-persons assertion is inadmissible without subject binding — LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z), and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 014891; board licence \"014664\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). The finding is actionable as an identity ticket; the dependent address adjudication is blocked. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Craig M Alexander", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "CURTIS ALEXANDER", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1073545752", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "014891" } ], "ticket": { "note": "fresh exact-identifier lookups on both sides, cited with URL, acquisition time and SHA-256 — observations of 2026-09-14 live CMS NPPES queries, not the pinned 2026-09-09 pool; never an auto-substituted identifier", "fresh_lookups": [ { "direction": "NPI→name/license", "url": "https://npiregistry.cms.hhs.gov/api/?number=1073545752&version=2.1", "acquired_at": "2026-09-14T06:05:55Z", "sha256": "31692acadc00a979ec2ac910ed28d2a520842fdb41cae82d72181fcea3ec27c3", "result": { "npi": "1073545752", "name": "CURTIS ALEXANDER", "mo_taxonomy_license": "014891 (Dentist, General Practice) — the board licence is 014664, a different number" } }, { "direction": "license→NPI (exact-name query)", "url": "https://npiregistry.cms.hhs.gov/api/?first_name=Craig&last_name=Alexander&version=2.1", "acquired_at": "2026-09-14T06:57:11Z", "sha256": "7bae9edf38e10566a4e87db36d7c17a829665b57acd7d70dd691ada1eed709aa", "result": { "npi": null, "name": "CRAIG ALEXANDER (4 NPPES records)", "mo_taxonomy_license": "NEGATIVE — none of the 4 Craig Alexander records carries MO taxonomy licence 014664; preserved at docs/reviews/astra/fresh-captures/craig-alexander.json" } } ] }, "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "CONTESTED", "finding_class": "identity-linkage", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the asserted NPI \"1073545752\" is registered in NPPES to \"CURTIS ALEXANDER\" (NPPES MO taxonomy license \"014891\"), while the board licence \"014664\" names \"Craig M Alexander\" — no identifier link establishes the NPI record as the same subject, and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 014891; board licence \"014664\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). This is the finding class a buyer pays for: an actionable identity ticket, never an auto-substituted identifier. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "CURTIS ALEXANDER", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1073545752", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "014891" }, { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Craig M Alexander", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ], "ticket": { "note": "fresh exact-identifier lookups on both sides, cited with URL, acquisition time and SHA-256 — observations of 2026-09-14 live CMS NPPES queries, not the pinned 2026-09-09 pool; never an auto-substituted identifier", "fresh_lookups": [ { "direction": "NPI→name/license", "url": "https://npiregistry.cms.hhs.gov/api/?number=1073545752&version=2.1", "acquired_at": "2026-09-14T06:05:55Z", "sha256": "31692acadc00a979ec2ac910ed28d2a520842fdb41cae82d72181fcea3ec27c3", "result": { "npi": "1073545752", "name": "CURTIS ALEXANDER", "mo_taxonomy_license": "014891 (Dentist, General Practice) — the board licence is 014664, a different number" } }, { "direction": "license→NPI (exact-name query)", "url": "https://npiregistry.cms.hhs.gov/api/?first_name=Craig&last_name=Alexander&version=2.1", "acquired_at": "2026-09-14T06:57:11Z", "sha256": "7bae9edf38e10566a4e87db36d7c17a829665b57acd7d70dd691ada1eed709aa", "result": { "npi": null, "name": "CRAIG ALEXANDER (4 NPPES records)", "mo_taxonomy_license": "NEGATIVE — none of the 4 Craig Alexander records carries MO taxonomy licence 014664; preserved at docs/reviews/astra/fresh-captures/craig-alexander.json" } } ] }, "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 014891; board licence \"014664\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality); dependent address adjudication is blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 (a)) temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "450 S Parker, Olathe, Kansas, 66061", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "300 S PLATTE CLAY WAY, KEARNEY, MO, 64060", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1073545752", "entity_type": "individual" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "300 S PLATTE CLAY WAY, KEARNEY, MO, 64060", "role": "mailing", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1073545752", "entity_type": "individual", "context": "mailing address preserved as context — never contradiction fodder" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-031", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Hitarth Maheshkumar Patel", "licence_number": "2025021095", "npi": "1437929213", "practice_address": "219 lillian place, Bartlett, MO, 60103" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-135", "join_evidence": "Near-miss names: board \"Hitarth Maheshkumar Patel\" vs NPPES \"HETAL PATEL\" — same last name, same first initial, not identical; no licence evidence." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": false, "evidence": "binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 2024022309; board licence \"2025021095\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2025021095", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "CONTESTED", "finding_class": "identity-linkage", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the board record for licence \"2025021095\" names \"Hitarth Maheshkumar Patel\"; the NPPES record for the asserted NPI \"1437929213\" names \"HETAL PATEL\" — with no Tier-A identifier link the corpora do not establish that these are two distinct published persons (a name-presentation variant remains possible; the two-persons assertion is inadmissible without subject binding — LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z), and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 2024022309; board licence \"2025021095\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). The finding is actionable as an identity ticket; the dependent address adjudication is blocked. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Hitarth Maheshkumar Patel", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "HETAL PATEL", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1437929213", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "2024022309" } ], "ticket": { "note": "fresh exact-identifier lookups on both sides, cited with URL, acquisition time and SHA-256 — observations of 2026-09-14 live CMS NPPES queries, not the pinned 2026-09-09 pool; never an auto-substituted identifier", "fresh_lookups": [ { "direction": "NPI→name/license", "url": "https://npiregistry.cms.hhs.gov/api/?number=1437929213&version=2.1", "acquired_at": "2026-09-14T06:06:02Z", "sha256": "9f58773ebc4d11d522e0a337b1f1cab52e75f4af661fdcb5099be34545a6051c", "result": { "npi": "1437929213", "name": "HETAL PATEL", "mo_taxonomy_license": "2024022309 (Dentist) — the board licence is 2025021095, a different number" } }, { "direction": "license→NPI (exact-name query)", "url": "https://npiregistry.cms.hhs.gov/api/?first_name=Hitarth&last_name=Patel&version=2.1", "acquired_at": "2026-09-14T06:57:11Z", "sha256": "de0a57b9527f2f0475591a8ffc9160475e55215932ddb1bd7c47d47f69583ba6", "result": { "npi": "1881580165", "name": "HITARTH PATEL", "mo_taxonomy_license": "2025021095 (Dentist) — EXACT MATCH to the buyer-published licence; preserved at docs/reviews/astra/fresh-captures/hitarth-patel.json" } } ] }, "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "CONTESTED", "finding_class": "identity-linkage", "reason": "identity-linkage unresolved (unsupported association): the asserted NPI \"1437929213\" is registered in NPPES to \"HETAL PATEL\" (NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2024022309\"), while the board licence \"2025021095\" names \"Hitarth Maheshkumar Patel\" — no identifier link establishes the NPI record as the same subject, and binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 2024022309; board licence \"2025021095\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality). This is the finding class a buyer pays for: an actionable identity ticket, never an auto-substituted identifier. temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "HETAL PATEL", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1437929213", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "2024022309" }, { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Hitarth Maheshkumar Patel", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" } ], "ticket": { "note": "fresh exact-identifier lookups on both sides, cited with URL, acquisition time and SHA-256 — observations of 2026-09-14 live CMS NPPES queries, not the pinned 2026-09-09 pool; never an auto-substituted identifier", "fresh_lookups": [ { "direction": "NPI→name/license", "url": "https://npiregistry.cms.hhs.gov/api/?number=1437929213&version=2.1", "acquired_at": "2026-09-14T06:06:02Z", "sha256": "9f58773ebc4d11d522e0a337b1f1cab52e75f4af661fdcb5099be34545a6051c", "result": { "npi": "1437929213", "name": "HETAL PATEL", "mo_taxonomy_license": "2024022309 (Dentist) — the board licence is 2025021095, a different number" } }, { "direction": "license→NPI (exact-name query)", "url": "https://npiregistry.cms.hhs.gov/api/?first_name=Hitarth&last_name=Patel&version=2.1", "acquired_at": "2026-09-14T06:57:11Z", "sha256": "de0a57b9527f2f0475591a8ffc9160475e55215932ddb1bd7c47d47f69583ba6", "result": { "npi": "1881580165", "name": "HITARTH PATEL", "mo_taxonomy_license": "2025021095 (Dentist) — EXACT MATCH to the buyer-published licence; preserved at docs/reviews/astra/fresh-captures/hitarth-patel.json" } } ] }, "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "UNVERIFIABLE", "reason": "binding not established — binding not established: no identifier equality — NPPES MO taxonomy license(s) on the asserted NPI record: 2024022309; board licence \"2025021095\". A name match alone is Tier-B and is refused as subject binding (kernel Tier-A requires identifier equality); dependent address adjudication is blocked (ADJUDICATION-2 (a)) temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "219 lillian place, Bartlett, Illinois, 60103", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "305 E OSAGE ST, PACIFIC, MO, 63069", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1437929213", "entity_type": "individual" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "305 E OSAGE ST, PACIFIC, MO, 63069", "role": "mailing", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1437929213", "entity_type": "individual", "context": "mailing address preserved as context — never contradiction fodder" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] }, { "row_id": "ROW-048", "record_class": "real-provider-row", "synthetic": false, "buyer_published": { "provider_name": "Timothy Balzen", "licence_number": "2025040537", "npi": "1467156174", "practice_address": "1427 W Great Basin Dr, Meridian, MO, 83646" }, "provenance": { "goldset_pair_id": "GS-040", "join_evidence": "NPPES taxonomy row carries MO license \"2025040537\" (taxonomy 1223G0001X); board license_number \"2025040537\"; join key: license string match (exact, after normalization)." }, "preconditions": { "subject_binding": { "established": true, "evidence": "Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2025040537\" = board licence \"2025040537\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)" }, "law_version": "ADJUDICATION-LAW-v8 (STATE-ALIAS-1 + CROSS-STATE-1 + LAW-IN-THE-BRANCH-1, Tani 2026-09-15T04:30Z — REPRO-DRIFT-1 gate + R7-8 rerun + forbidden assertions enforced in the emitting branch)" }, "propositions": [ { "field": "licence_number", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published licence number matches the pinned board roster record for this licence (board status \"Active\", expires 2026-11-30 — in force at evaluation)", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "2025040537", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "status": "Active", "expires_at": "2026-11-30" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "provider_name", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the buyer-published name matches the board roster name under the published name law, and the NPPES record for the asserted NPI names the same person (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2025040537\" = board licence \"2025040537\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "Timothy Balzen", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "TIMOTHY BALZEN", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1467156174", "entity_type": "individual" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "npi", "state": "VERIFIED", "reason": "the asserted NPI exists in the pinned NPPES pool, and the NPPES-registered name matches the board roster name under the published name law (subject binding: Tier-A identifier equality: NPPES MO taxonomy license \"2025040537\" = board licence \"2025040537\" after normalization (CROSSWALK-DETERMINISTIC-1)). temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "TIMOTHY BALZEN", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1467156174", "entity_type": "individual", "taxonomy_license": "2025040537" } ], "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } }, { "field": "practice_address", "state": "CONTESTED", "reason": "cross-state mismatch (CROSS-STATE-1, R7-8 rerun — Tani 2026-09-15T00:33Z): EXTRACT-1 history — our parser produced the \"MO\" — the board publishes Meridian, IDAHO 83646 (ba_state \"Idaho\" in the raw row); the parsed canonical carries state: None for this licence and the reading renderer defaulted to MO — an extraction defect, never a board publication — the defect was OURS (SERVICE-DEBT-1); the parser fix landed and THIS rerun, at our expense, emits the finding the blocked comparison owed: the buyer publishes the practice in Missouri while the board's address of record is out-of-state (state MO vs IDAHO) temporal scope: board reading as of 2026-08-10 vs NPPES reading as of 2026-09-09 vs buyer publication frozen 2026-09-13 — non-contemporaneous readings; the comparison is bounded by that window", "readings": [ { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10 (parsed-DEN.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "6cc59cb705497a76920ce57d1deeedfc81e67ae486fb2a52296d3d7e4b40c7f4", "value": "1427 W Great Basin Dr, Meridian, Idaho, 83646", "role": "address_of_record", "as_of": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "parsed_render": "the parser-fixed rendering — the board row’s true state preserved (EXTRACT-1 resolved)" }, { "authority": "CMS NPPES", "artifact": "NPPES registry fetch 2026-09-09 (pool.canonical.json)", "artifact_sha256": "0131fe216272dda200bff661ddb39ff22a03abaee34d21e6a4888d3d7b055e39", "value": "1217 E MAIN ST, LINN, MO, 65051", "role": "practice location", "as_of": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "npi": "1467156174", "entity_type": "individual" }, { "authority": "Missouri Board of Dentistry — RAW SOURCE", "artifact": "DEN.TXT drop 2026-08-10, raw line (shipped: engagement-corpora/DEN.TXT)", "value": "Timothy Balzen — ba_address \"1427 W Great Basin Dr\", ba_city \"Meridian\", ba_state \"Idaho\", ba_zip \"83646\" (raw DEN.TXT line 3888, shipped: engagement-corpora/DEN.TXT)" } ], "source_reading": { "raw_line": 3888, "raw": "Timothy Balzen — ba_address \"1427 W Great Basin Dr\", ba_city \"Meridian\", ba_state \"Idaho\", ba_zip \"83646\" (raw DEN.TXT line 3888, shipped: engagement-corpora/DEN.TXT)", "verdict": "our parser produced the \"MO\" — the board publishes Meridian, IDAHO 83646 (ba_state \"Idaho\" in the raw row); the parsed canonical carries state: None for this licence and the reading renderer defaulted to MO — an extraction defect, never a board publication" }, "freshness": { "label": "HISTORICAL-FINDING", "evaluation_time": "2026-09-14T20:51:58.210Z", "corpora_windows": { "board": "2026-08-10 (DEN.TXT drop date)", "nppes": "2026-09-09 (NPPES pool fetch)", "buyer_freeze": "2026-09-13T14:38:33Z (sample freeze)" }, "freshness_contract": "NOT a current verification record — this proposition carries no verified_at/next_required_by under the production freshness contract (records-publish v2 / FRESHNESS-POLICY-1). It is valid evidence of what was found at the stated evaluation time against the pinned corpora, and is never presented as current verification; a relying party requiring current verification must use the production record path. This engagement schema is not a second, weaker verification kernel." } } ] } ], "signature": "mLrAAYc1QcZGfwK/VGgrYIZ+FqLwwNqc7tMc84Ww6LiFKWV0YyB6O7blHhf5X2O+b8RvO1wLhnyPdDiFy+69BA==" }