SUPERSEDED — this signed version is part of the append-only trail and is not the current version of this record. Current version: sample-audit-current@2
Verification record
Word of Clout self-audit procedure
Self-audit record — Word of Clout’s own verification procedure, stated and signed. It asserts nothing about any practitioner; it is the audit of our own work.
This record states and signs Word of Clout's own sampling procedure: the frame, the draw, the retained ids, the error definition, the procedure faults, and the bound. It is an audit of our own verification work — it asserts nothing about any practitioner. Read the bound as what it is: an upper limit on our own re-derivation error, not a score of any source, any plan, or any provider.
The self-audit procedure — stated and signed
Other findings
The frame is every verification row recorded in woc_kernel at cutoff 2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z; the frame's row count is not recorded in the run receipt — the estimator and the bound do not depend on it
Source: sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 · observed Sep 07, 2026 04:36 UTC · evidence
A server-side random sample of 50 verification rows was drawn, deduplicated by id; all 50 drawn ids are retained in the cited receipt artifact
Source: sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 · observed Sep 07, 2026 04:36 UTC · evidence
The drawn-ids artifact is the run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (/srv/woc-kernel/state/self-audit/sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out), sha256 4a763180b1aa2c92dc48cdd49f8016d0ac079846f8823e8f869aa5970497e83b — 50 distinct verification ids
Source: sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 · observed Sep 07, 2026 04:36 UTC · evidence
The estimand is the proportion of verification rows in woc_kernel whose stored verdict disagrees with the verdict re-derived under the sampler's independent support rule, among re-derivable rows, at cutoff 2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z; procedure faults are recorded and excluded from the rate, and provider aggregation is descriptive only, with no bound
Source: sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 · observed Sep 07, 2026 04:36 UTC · evidence
1 procedure fault: re-derivation could not be performed for ver:board:mo-dental:2025005314:address_of_record:2026-09-04@old — recorded, excluded from the rate denominator, never counted as agree (PROCEDURE-FAULT-1, Tani 2026-09-19T01:07Z)
Source: sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 · observed Sep 07, 2026 04:36 UTC · evidence
0 disagreements in 49 re-derived rows; the exact one-sided 95% binomial upper bound on the frame error rate is 1 − 0.05^(1/49) = 5.93% ≈ 5.9%
Source: sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 · observed Sep 07, 2026 04:36 UTC · evidence
Technical section — signed and recorded material shown verbatim
Per-proposition provenance — verbatim from the record
frame · VERIFIED
verification: —
artifact cited: —
evidence extract: board-frame.json
observation: OBSERVED — run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out, sha256:4a763180b1aa2c92…, ts 2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z
authority: sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1
comparison rule: sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 · freshness policy: unmeasured
applicable rule: POLICY — quarterly cadence, 90d from the run cutoff; labeled POLICY, never MEASURED
draw · VERIFIED
verification: —
artifact cited: —
evidence extract: board-draw.json
observation: OBSERVED — run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out, sha256:4a763180b1aa2c92…, ts 2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z
authority: sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1
comparison rule: sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 · freshness policy: unmeasured
applicable rule: POLICY — quarterly cadence, 90d from the run cutoff; labeled POLICY, never MEASURED
ids artifact · VERIFIED
verification: —
artifact cited: —
evidence extract: board-ids_artifact.json
observation: OBSERVED — run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out, sha256:4a763180b1aa2c92…, ts 2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z
authority: sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1
comparison rule: sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 · freshness policy: unmeasured
applicable rule: POLICY — quarterly cadence, 90d from the run cutoff; labeled POLICY, never MEASURED
error definition · VERIFIED
verification: —
artifact cited: —
evidence extract: board-error_definition.json
observation: OBSERVED — run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out, sha256:4a763180b1aa2c92…, ts 2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z
authority: sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1
comparison rule: sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 · freshness policy: unmeasured
applicable rule: POLICY — quarterly cadence, 90d from the run cutoff; labeled POLICY, never MEASURED
procedure faults · VERIFIED
verification: —
artifact cited: —
evidence extract: board-procedure_faults.json
observation: OBSERVED — run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out, sha256:4a763180b1aa2c92…, ts 2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z
authority: sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1
comparison rule: sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 · freshness policy: unmeasured
applicable rule: POLICY — quarterly cadence, 90d from the run cutoff; labeled POLICY, never MEASURED
bound · VERIFIED
verification: —
artifact cited: —
evidence extract: board-bound.json
observation: OBSERVED — run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out, sha256:4a763180b1aa2c92…, ts 2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z
authority: sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1
comparison rule: sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 · freshness policy: unmeasured
applicable rule: POLICY — quarterly cadence, 90d from the run cutoff; labeled POLICY, never MEASURED
Record id
sample-audit-current
Read from the records ledger at request time
Verified at
Sep 07, 2026 04:36 UTC
when the supporting evidence was captured
Method
Authority file read, Ed25519 over the canonical form
each check reads an authority's published file and signs the result
Observation age
Sep 07, 2026 04:36 UTC
when this historical observation was captured (reliance lives only on the current version of this record)
Superseded by
none — superseded by sample-audit-current@2
reliance lives only on the current version of this record; this page is the historical trail and renders no reliance approval
Public key
Ed25519 (SPKI) — shown in full below
embedded in this record
Signed scope — machine-replayable field enumeration; the sentences state their meaning
The signature covers exactly: id, schema, subject, created_at (the EVIDENCE CUTOFF — the newest evidence timestamp in the derived snapshot, NOT the issuance time), issued_at (the issuance time of THIS record, distinct from the evidence cutoff — a record can never acquire an earlier issuance time because its evidence is older), public_key, propositions (four-state verdicts only, POLICY next_required_by = min(90d interval, authority-stated expiry at 00:00 America/Chicago)), candidate_relations (evidence joins carrying no verdict), dependency_manifest, dependency_manifest_sha256, signed_scope_note, supersedes — every field except signature, signing, and derivation. The derivation block (the queries that produced this record) is display metadata, excluded from signing. dependency_manifest_sha256 is the SHA-256 hex of stableStringify(dependency_manifest) — the canonical recipe (key-sorted, no whitespace), the same recipe as this record's own canonical form (R4-4/I16: equal manifest values hash equally regardless of stored key order).
Signature
sha256:418055e8a31fabe9… Ed25519
re-computed at this render
-----BEGIN PUBLIC KEY-----
MCowBQYDK2VwAyEAZAXc8TrIl05HTq4oDHbsc2Qf8SA6pydv3jbaUV4kSyA=
-----END PUBLIC KEY-----
How this record was derived — its provenance, repeat it yourself
This self-audit record is DERIVED from the cited sample-audit run receipt bytes, re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1: a re-derivation that cannot be performed is a procedure fault — recorded, excluded from the rate, never agree. Every figure is traceable to the receipt; the receipt is cited by name and sha256 and embedded below. The prior published bound (computed on the old law that counted the fault row as agree) is history with that reason; this record carries the honest numbers.
queries (format label absent — unlabeled machine block)
read the run receipt /srv/woc-kernel/state/self-audit/sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (sha256 4a763180b1aa2c92dc48cdd49f8016d0ac079846f8823e8f869aa5970497e83b)
re-parse under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1: outcome not_rederivable OR (expected not-rederivable-false AND actual false) → procedure fault, excluded from n
bound = 1 − 0.05^(1/49)
db.published_records.find({ id: 'sample-audit-current' }).sort({ 'signing.signed_at': -1 }).limit(1)
Verify this yourself — three independent checks
Material class: self_audit — this record audits Word of Clout's own procedure. It asserts nothing about any practitioner.
This is the record's canonical form. Ed25519 signature verification runs in your browser using a pure-JS implementation — no browser fallback, no SHA-256-only digest comparison passing as verification. Nothing is sent to us.
{"candidate_relations":[],"created_at":"2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z","dependency_manifest":{"bound":{"approx":5.9,"exact":0.059306014189697054,"formula":"1 − 0.05^(1/49)","percent":5.93},"draw":{"board_licence_units":42,"distinct_provider_units":50,"drawn":50,"nppes_npi_units":8,"provider_aggregation":"descriptive only, no bound"},"evaluation_cutoff":"2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z","receipt":{"bytes":14731,"citation":"/srv/woc-kernel/state/self-audit/sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out","name":"sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out","sha256":"4a763180b1aa2c92dc48cdd49f8016d0ac079846f8823e8f869aa5970497e83b"},"reparse":{"disagree":0,"distinct_ids":50,"drawn":50,"law":"PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 (Tani 2026-09-19T01:07Z)","procedure_fault_ids":["ver:board:mo-dental:2025005314:address_of_record:2026-09-04@old"],"procedure_faults":1,"re_derived":49},"ruleset_version":"woc.records-publish.ruleset.self-audit.v1","sampler_report_next_sample_size":100},"dependency_manifest_sha256":"baca59b409e815dcb5b7fed269bc26c1361dee6fd2736ab96a4a26e87d87ae3e","id":"sample-audit-current","issued_at":"2026-09-19T02:14:41.254Z","propositions":[{"authority":"sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1","decay_class":"unmeasured","id":"self-audit:frame","method":"re-parse of the run receipt bytes under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 (a re-derivation that cannot be performed is a procedure fault — recorded, excluded, never agree)","next_required_by":"2026-12-06T04:36:37.637Z","proposition":"The frame is every verification row recorded in woc_kernel at cutoff 2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z; the frame's row count is not recorded in the run receipt — the estimator and the bound do not depend on it","provenance":{"next_required_by_source":"POLICY — quarterly cadence, 90d from the run cutoff; labeled POLICY, never MEASURED","verified_at_source":"OBSERVED — run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out, sha256:4a763180b1aa2c92…, ts 2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z"},"state":"VERIFIED","verified_at":"2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z"},{"authority":"sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1","decay_class":"unmeasured","id":"self-audit:draw","method":"re-parse of the run receipt bytes under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 (a re-derivation that cannot be performed is a procedure fault — recorded, excluded, never agree)","next_required_by":"2026-12-06T04:36:37.637Z","proposition":"A server-side random sample of 50 verification rows was drawn, deduplicated by id; all 50 drawn ids are retained in the cited receipt artifact","provenance":{"next_required_by_source":"POLICY — quarterly cadence, 90d from the run cutoff; labeled POLICY, never MEASURED","verified_at_source":"OBSERVED — run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out, sha256:4a763180b1aa2c92…, ts 2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z"},"state":"VERIFIED","verified_at":"2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z"},{"authority":"sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1","decay_class":"unmeasured","id":"self-audit:ids_artifact","method":"re-parse of the run receipt bytes under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 (a re-derivation that cannot be performed is a procedure fault — recorded, excluded, never agree)","next_required_by":"2026-12-06T04:36:37.637Z","proposition":"The drawn-ids artifact is the run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (/srv/woc-kernel/state/self-audit/sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out), sha256 4a763180b1aa2c92dc48cdd49f8016d0ac079846f8823e8f869aa5970497e83b — 50 distinct verification ids","provenance":{"next_required_by_source":"POLICY — quarterly cadence, 90d from the run cutoff; labeled POLICY, never MEASURED","verified_at_source":"OBSERVED — run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out, sha256:4a763180b1aa2c92…, ts 2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z"},"state":"VERIFIED","verified_at":"2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z"},{"authority":"sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1","decay_class":"unmeasured","id":"self-audit:error_definition","method":"re-parse of the run receipt bytes under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 (a re-derivation that cannot be performed is a procedure fault — recorded, excluded, never agree)","next_required_by":"2026-12-06T04:36:37.637Z","proposition":"The estimand is the proportion of verification rows in woc_kernel whose stored verdict disagrees with the verdict re-derived under the sampler's independent support rule, among re-derivable rows, at cutoff 2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z; procedure faults are recorded and excluded from the rate, and provider aggregation is descriptive only, with no bound","provenance":{"next_required_by_source":"POLICY — quarterly cadence, 90d from the run cutoff; labeled POLICY, never MEASURED","verified_at_source":"OBSERVED — run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out, sha256:4a763180b1aa2c92…, ts 2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z"},"state":"VERIFIED","verified_at":"2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z"},{"authority":"sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1","decay_class":"unmeasured","id":"self-audit:procedure_faults","method":"re-parse of the run receipt bytes under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 (a re-derivation that cannot be performed is a procedure fault — recorded, excluded, never agree)","next_required_by":"2026-12-06T04:36:37.637Z","proposition":"1 procedure fault: re-derivation could not be performed for ver:board:mo-dental:2025005314:address_of_record:2026-09-04@old — recorded, excluded from the rate denominator, never counted as agree (PROCEDURE-FAULT-1, Tani 2026-09-19T01:07Z)","provenance":{"next_required_by_source":"POLICY — quarterly cadence, 90d from the run cutoff; labeled POLICY, never MEASURED","verified_at_source":"OBSERVED — run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out, sha256:4a763180b1aa2c92…, ts 2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z"},"state":"VERIFIED","verified_at":"2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z"},{"authority":"sample-audit run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out (op sample-audit, read identity, run-pinned host op) — re-parsed under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1","decay_class":"unmeasured","id":"self-audit:bound","method":"re-parse of the run receipt bytes under PROCEDURE-FAULT-1 (a re-derivation that cannot be performed is a procedure fault — recorded, excluded, never agree)","next_required_by":"2026-12-06T04:36:37.637Z","proposition":"0 disagreements in 49 re-derived rows; the exact one-sided 95% binomial upper bound on the frame error rate is 1 − 0.05^(1/49) = 5.93% ≈ 5.9%","provenance":{"next_required_by_source":"POLICY — quarterly cadence, 90d from the run cutoff; labeled POLICY, never MEASURED","verified_at_source":"OBSERVED — run receipt sample-audit-20260907T043637Z.out, sha256:4a763180b1aa2c92…, ts 2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z"},"state":"VERIFIED","verified_at":"2026-09-07T04:36:37.637Z"}],"public_key":"-----BEGIN PUBLIC KEY-----\nMCowBQYDK2VwAyEAZAXc8TrIl05HTq4oDHbsc2Qf8SA6pydv3jbaUV4kSyA=\n-----END PUBLIC KEY-----","schema":"woc.record.v1","signed_scope_note":"The signature covers exactly: id, schema, subject, created_at (the EVIDENCE CUTOFF — the newest evidence timestamp in the derived snapshot, NOT the issuance time), issued_at (the issuance time of THIS record, distinct from the evidence cutoff — a record can never acquire an earlier issuance time because its evidence is older), public_key, propositions (four-state verdicts only, POLICY next_required_by = min(90d interval, authority-stated expiry at 00:00 America/Chicago)), candidate_relations (evidence joins carrying no verdict), dependency_manifest, dependency_manifest_sha256, signed_scope_note, supersedes — every field except signature, signing, and derivation. The derivation block (the queries that produced this record) is display metadata, excluded from signing. dependency_manifest_sha256 is the SHA-256 hex of stableStringify(dependency_manifest) — the canonical recipe (key-sorted, no whitespace), the same recipe as this record's own canonical form (R4-4/I16: equal manifest values hash equally regardless of stored key order).","subject":"Word of Clout self-audit procedure"}
published digest 418055e8a31fabe958cf628d295b1d82318a944492c061430626675720803fe9
your browser —
If a published number cannot be re-derived from the ledger with the public key, it is a claim, and the record carrying it is void. That rule binds us before it binds anyone else.